Heritage Gallery Auctions, NY - Read over 94 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Heritage Gallery Auctions (94)

badge TOP RATED
4.5 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 94 Reviews

John
Lovettsville, VA

Jan 28, 2026
Japanese Cloisonne Trinket Box

Evan
Chillicothe, OH

Jan 24, 2026
My first purchase with an auction
This was my first purchase using an online auction so I was a little bit nervous not knowing how the whole process worked. I did call Heritage Auctions to let them know I was working on getting a shipper. They were responsive to my needs. Thanks!
Report
Heavily Carved Victorian Needlepoint Fire Screen

Marc
Sarasota, FL

Jan 22, 2026
Amazing experience-thank you
Top notch-extremely satisfied-utmost professional interaction
Report
Embossed Coca Cola Bottle Metal Advertising Thermometer Donasco

Phillip
Chapel Hill, NC

Jan 22, 2026
Jack Frankfurter O/C Boy Hanging the Sails, c.1970s

American Pawn Company
North Fort Myers, FL

Jan 14, 2026
Items as described
Item as described we recommend
Report
Mid Century 10k Yellow Gold & Onyx Class Ring Size 7

Gregory
New Orleans, LA

Jan 08, 2026
Great Selection and Price!
I love this item! Just received it today! I will definitely follow this auctioneer for future awesome finds. Thank you very much and Happy New Year!
Report
Heritage Gallery Auctions logo
Heritage Gallery AuctionsJan 10, 2026
Thank you!
Heavy Sterling Silver Men's Link Bracelet

Clifford
Mattituck, NY

Jan 07, 2026
Vintage 1920s Native American Skookum Doll Man & Woman

John
Memphis, TN

Dec 21, 2025
No Fuss and Excellent 3rd Party Shipper
I am enjoying my great bargain finds from Heritage Gallery Auction. Easy going staff there. If you purchase items here that can be shipped by FedEx/UPS I highly recommend enlisting Anthony at East End Pack and Ship for excellent packaging and very reasonable rates.
Report
Brutalist Mid Century Curtis Jere Style Lamp

Larry
Los Angeles, CA

Dec 21, 2025
Allen Blagden New England W/C Snowy Landscape

Jillian
Westport, CT

Dec 16, 2025
Van Briggle Ming Blue Acorn Oak Leaf Bowl

Jillian
Westport, CT

Dec 16, 2025
Rookwood Grape & Leaf Motif Art Pottery Vase #2604

Chris
Sherman Oaks, CA

Dec 09, 2025
Hap Sakwa Torus Turned Bowl

Tracee
Adrian, MI

Dec 09, 2025
Great Communication and Fantastic Customer Service
I just received the items that I won from Heritage Gallery Auctions. Everything was better than described. The items were packaged with care and arrived quickly. I will strive to bid with this auction house again. Thank you.
Report
Lot of (15) Antique Eye Glasses

Gloria
East Setauket, NY

Nov 23, 2025
Perfect Auction Experience!
Love this painting.
Report
Joseph Reboli O/C Long Island Barn Landscape, 1974

Scott
Toronto, CA

Nov 17, 2025
19th Century Tramp Art Frame

Carol
San Antonio, TX

Nov 16, 2025
Great experience
The description of the item was able was spot on. The shipping & packaging was excellent as the item had several fragile components. Everyone with Heritage was helpful and answered all my questions in a timely fashion. It has been a pleasure doing business with Heritage Gallery Auctions.
Report
Wicker Basket with (5) Ostridge Eggs

Benjamin
Kyneton, AU

Nov 06, 2025
A +
A +
Report
Vintage Zodiac Sea Wolf Automatic with Date Wristwatch

Gintaras
Vilnius, LT

Nov 02, 2025
Jaeger Le Coultre Atmos Mantel Clock

Elliott
Atlanta, GA

Oct 07, 2025
Attb. to Maison Bagues Pair of French Candelabras

Tony
Brightwood, VA

Oct 06, 2025
Another Enjoyable Experience at Heritage Gallery Auctions
This was my second time participating in an auction at Heritage Gallery Auctions. The pace of the live auction was ideal, not too slow like it is at some auction houses. I also liked the video and audio feed during the auction. There is a UPS Store right near their location that will pick up your purchases and pack them up and send them to you. I opted to have my regular shipper pick up my purchases because of the large size of the statues. Overall, it was a very enjoyable experience, and I look forward to participating in other auctions at Heritage Gallery Auctions.
Report
Heritage Gallery Auctions logo
Heritage Gallery AuctionsOct 09, 2025
Thank you!
19th Century Meissen Bronze Mounted Center Plate

Drew
Rutland, VT

Oct 06, 2025
Nice storefront Auction House
Tidy storefront auction house, very transparent with on line and streamed in person auctions. Very helpful with arrangements and with pick-up. Good documentation and communication. I'd bid with them again.
Report
Heritage Gallery Auctions logo
Heritage Gallery AuctionsOct 09, 2025
Thank you!
Large Inuit Soapstone Sculpture "Mother and Child" Johnny Inukpuk

Jay
Summerland, CA

Oct 06, 2025
Vintage Native American Navajo Saddle Blanket / Rug

Lynn
Atlanta, GA

Oct 05, 2025
Vintage Heri Mora (Mata Ortiz, Mexico, 20th c.) Art Pottery Vase Butterflies

Kan
Plano, TX

Oct 04, 2025
Heritage Gallery Auctions logo
Heritage Gallery AuctionsOct 04, 2025
Thank you!
Pair Signed Meiji Period Asian Carved Bone Figures Okimono

Gregg
Los Angeles, CA

Aug 27, 2025
I was given a shipper who was highly recommended by the owner. the lamp came in damaged.
terrible people. recommended a shipper that was not good. item came severely damaged. the owner of the auction house said she couldn't help me and hung up on me. stay away from these people
Report
Heritage Gallery Auctions logo
Heritage Gallery AuctionsAug 29, 2025
As we do not ship, we recommend shippers who we have successfully used. Damage happens, and I tried to explain to you that you needed to put in an insurance claim with the shipper, but you just kept screaming at me. I do not tolerate being spoken to that way, so I hung up. Sellers, beware of agressive, uncooperative buyer. I tried to speak, but all you did was scream at me.
Mid Century Robert Sonneman "Orbiter" Floor Lamp

Jeremy
Redding, CT

Aug 25, 2025
An effortless transaction. Quick, well-packed shipping. Item as described.
An effortless transaction. Quick, well-packed shipping. Item as described.
Report
Heritage Gallery Auctions logo
Heritage Gallery AuctionsAug 29, 2025
Thank you!
Art Deco Raymonde GUERBE (1894-1995) "Jericho" in raw zinc Max le Verrier workshop

Kenneth
Saint Louis, MO

Aug 24, 2025
Pioneer PL-540 PLL Quartz Automatic Return Turntable

CYNTHIA
Nottingham, NH

Jul 16, 2025
A +
A +, quick shipping.
Report
Ephraim Pottery Lily Vase Alek Schroeder

Rochelle
Palm Beach Gardens, FL

Jun 13, 2025
c1905 English Cut Crystal & Reticulated Sterling Silver Collar Perfume

Alexander
Chalfont, PA

May 02, 2025
Great Test of Patience
Auction house not very eager to ship or assist with shipping process. Took over a month to receive item after a fiasco with one of their recommended shippers. Shipper held item hostage and then finally when auction house recovered item to use another shipper, it was double the original cost. Horrible customer service. Don’t use this auction house if you are expecting quick turnaround. Auction house should’ve offered to cover the shipping to keep the customer happy but instead I was charged double than originally quoted by the lackluster company.
Report
Heritage Gallery Auctions logo
Heritage Gallery AuctionsMay 02, 2025
We held a 400 lot auction, and 250 + lots were picked up within the week, because those clients contacted a shipper on our list or contacted us for assistance. You contacted the shipper over 2 weeks later. Shipper sent you an invoice a few days after he picked up the item, but you were unhappy. We reached out to you, on a Sunday afternoon to rectify the situation, and personally drove out and picked the item to give to the other shipper you decided to go with, after complaining about the cost. I am confused as to why you say the customer service is inept. It sees that you were angling for free shipping. We do not facilitate shipping, so not sure why you say we charged you double. Auction houses beware of problem buyer.
A. Barbini Murano Double Fish Art Glass Sculpture

Stan
Rensselaer, NY

Apr 26, 2025
I like bidding at this auction house.
I like bidding at this auction house. Responsive and made it easy to work with every time I use them.
Report
Lot of Lionel Trains & Accessories 2035

Charles E.
Topsham, ME

Apr 21, 2025
5 Louis Priscilla Lingerie Pin Up Illustrations Fun Year Book

Daniel
Farmville, NC

Apr 20, 2025
Lot of 4 Tin Litho Battery Toys

Christian
New Wilmington, PA

Apr 20, 2025
Signed CORDOBA Impressionist Industrial Harbor Cityscape

Jennifer
Rockville Centre, NY

Mar 09, 2025
Jean Francois Millet Lithograph Titled "LES GLANEUSES"

Anthony
New York, NY

Mar 09, 2025
Shipped fast and secure.
The process was great. They communicated clearly, shipped fast and packaging was secure for a delicate object. Great overall experience. I wish everyone was as professional!
Report
Mid Century Modernist Jaru Ceramic & 24 Carat Gold Plated Vessel

JOHN
Warren, PA

Mar 09, 2025
Easy to work with
Easy to contact and work with for shipping/pickup
Report
c1910 Lot of 7 British Crabtree Brass & Enamel Light Switches

Dennis
Basye, VA

Mar 04, 2025
Dali Rembrandt
I got it. (Well packed) I like it. Now I gotta frame it. A +
Report
Salvador Dali Drypoint Etching Titled Rembrandt in Sepia

Jon
Reykjavík, IS

Dec 23, 2024
Great service
profession and very good in every way
Report
Gunnella O/C Folk Art First Birthday Cake Titled Happy Birthday

Sandi
Edmonds, WA

Dec 22, 2024
Painting as advertised; shipping took as long as similar items shipped from Australia?!?
*
Report
Rosie Napangardi O/C Titled Yuelamu Women's Dreaming

Susan
Chapel Hill, NC

Dec 22, 2024
Mid Century Modern Spaghetti Shade Table Lamp

Frank
Island Park, NY

Dec 01, 2024
14k White Gold Diamond Teardrop Earrings

Brad
Winter Haven, FL

Nov 24, 2024
Pair of 19th Century Carved Giltwood Architectural Element Cherubs

James
Laguna Vista, TX

Nov 17, 2024
Baccarat Oceanie Decanter with Millefiori Stopper

Beverly
Schertz, TX

Nov 17, 2024
Great service and quality.
Great service
Report
Swedish Kosta Boda Kjell Engman Art Glass Footed Bowl Original Box

Ron
Scarsdale, NY

Nov 17, 2024
Quality Auction, very professional
Easy to bid and pay.
Report
19th Century Chinese Double Sword with Shagreen & Brass Mounted Sheath

Semyon
Philadelphia, PA

Nov 17, 2024
18/19th Century Portrait Miniature in Ebonized Wood Frame

Patricia
Wading River, NY

Nov 17, 2024
Great experience. Items as described, easy pickup
Would do business with again. Very easy transaction
Report
19th Century Brass Inlaid Rosewood Tea Caddy

Jason
Wilmington, CA

Oct 31, 2024
No regard for repeat buyer who spent $4, 700 this time around
I purchased 6 lots totaling almost $5, 000 in my most recent purchase from Heritage Auction Gallery. HAG relies on you to look at the photo's instead of written providing condition reports on their lots, except for when they actually do post condition notes in which case they are not accurate, misleading and not helpful. So why would they bother to post anything about the condition when it is not accurate and they don't stand behind it? Who knows. A bronze sculpture I purchased had significant wear to the finish, I thought it was a rustic finish in the photos, no condition was stated. A silver teapot had a missing piece in the handle, this was obvious and photographed really well but no condition provided. A silver card box I purchased stated "Overall good condition, see photos." I could see some of the condition issues but no where near all of them. It is in decidedly POOR condition. Also, I contacted them but they did not bother to reply.
Report
Heritage Gallery Auctions logo
Heritage Gallery AuctionsNov 18, 2024
The buyer sent one email but didn't ask any questions, just that the piece was in "poor" condition so we really didn't know if he wanted something or was just stating displeasure with the item. As we are not experts on everything, we take multiple photos for the buyer to judge condition, and if there are questions, we have no problem elaborating on the photos or adding more if needed. We will always answer any questions whether via email or phone call. Sorry you had a bad experience.
Tiffany & Co. Makers Sterling Silver Bowl (1907-1947)

Didier
Paley, FR

Oct 02, 2024
Efficiency
Trust
Report
Vintage Mobil Pegasus Porcelain Coated Gas Sign