Bidder Reviews for Bonanza Auctions (35)
4.3 out of 5.0 Stars
1-35 of 35 Reviews
RochellePalm Beach Gardens, FL
Dec 29, 2025

MarjorieAlbuquerque, NM
Dec 29, 2025
Great experience
A great experience-the catalog photos were quite good. However the descriptions could have been more specific and more measurements would have been good. As they do in-house shipping, they were able to give a shipping fee estimate before bidding so one knows the approximate total cost. The auction terms were very clear. The live bidding worked very well. The shipping was reasonable (as auction house shipping goes) and very well packed. I was very pleased.

WilliamLincolnton, NC
Nov 10, 2025

KelvinKennesaw, GA
Nov 10, 2025

DonFarmington, MI
Nov 10, 2025

LYonkers, NY
Oct 29, 2025
the worse experience. I ever had and am a regular on this site website
The shipping came in multiple boxes, very poorly packed, very various expensive on the shipment. Bad bad

MarionWestminster, CA
Sep 18, 2025

CrawfordLondon, GB
Sep 15, 2025

RobinSouth Hamilton, MA
Sep 15, 2025

ClouRock Hall, MD
Sep 05, 2025
Bonanza Bidders Beware
I won several lots. 1. One lot was described incorrectly-items are too large and useless to me. 2. Another lot was not packaged properly and an antique glass item arrived broken, despite the $86 in shipping I was charged. I am accustomed to the shipping overcharges of auction houses, but in exchange I expect to receive items intact. (The antique treasure survived one hundred years, but couldn't survive the ineptitude of this auction house). 3. Lastly, and perhaps most important! y, the auction house did not respond to my messages requesting partial refund to rectify THEIR errors. I have a lot of buying experience from other auction houses for comparison sake. This experience is the worst by far. I have blocked this auction house from showing up in future searches on Liveauctioneers.
Bonanza AuctionsSep 08, 2025
1) This buyer wrote after business close Friday. Today is Monday. Hardly not responsive. 2) The "poorly packaged item" was placed in poly fill and then boxed, more poly fill, then boxed again and placed in a larger box with other items. Hardly improper. 3) The item wasn't actually even broken. They made it up. 4) Buyer demanded more money back than they paid for the auction lot. 5) Buyer then tried to return another lot because they said it was described wrong with the wrong size/dimensions. Unfortunately measurements were shown and the buyer completely fabricated another "issue" to magically force a return. In other words this is fraud. This is a bad buyer. It confounds me how any of these issues could be our fault. It is also confounding how we could have improved service. The item wasn't broken. The other lot was described correctly. This buyer wasn't billed for packaging materials. They weren't billed for labor and the package for 7 lots cost more to mail than $86. Not to mention it shipped in less than 24 hours after payment.

NickPalm Coast, FL
Apr 27, 2025
AlexanderLittle River, CA
Apr 13, 2025
CarlRidgewood, NJ
Feb 13, 2025
AlexandraPortland, OR
Oct 15, 2024
Fast and easy shipping, professional service
Very cool vintage items and professional service provided. I will come back and bid again.

Brad Tulsa, OK
Oct 06, 2024

Anthony PSouthold, NY
May 20, 2024

KarlReno, NV
May 19, 2024

GordyBaton Rouge, LA
May 19, 2024
How helpful they were with a first time bid winner.
Could not have asked for a more friendly crew. Glad to have done business with Bonanza!

Hamilton Duluth, MN
May 19, 2024

MichaelTerre Haute, IN
May 08, 2024
Medical scrubs and used pillows for packing material. Excessive Shipping Charges
I bought 6 lots. They were, an aluminum toy truck, three tin toy cars, a diecast and steel toy truck and a paper and wood toy airplane. Shipped in 5 separate boxes? They charged me $248 to ship them! I will be honest, there was no damage, but $248 and in individual boxes.?? I assume that allowed them to ship all but one, USPS Ground. The packaging material included a used stained pillow and pillowcase and discarded medical scrubs. Yes, same as another reviewer had posted and the auction house responded stating the buyer '"makes things up". When I questioned the auction house about this and the excessive shipping charges, they referred to me, or my message as, "mockingly ignorant", and said I had "no right to complain". There were other condescending and demeaning remarks, but it was all unprofessional and insulting. You decide but bid with caution!
Bonanza AuctionsMay 08, 2024
Shipping was pre-quoted before the bids were even placed. He knew up front before he bought the stuff. 5 Large boxes went out. The charges to the buyer didn't even cover the actual postage. He was never asked to make up the difference. Moreso, the buyer was NOT charged for boxes, was NOT charged for packaging materials and was NOT charged for labor to wrap or ship. The packages shipped in under 48 hours from payment. They were all delivered in less than 7 days from auction close. The lightning fast service this buyer received is almost beyond comparison, especially on liveauctioneers. When confronted with the details he decided to ridicule the packaging materials. Lets be blunt: poly fill is a recycled material used in teddy bears, couches, pillows, sleeping bags, batting, ect. It can be bought from craft stores and other hobbyist or business supplies. It is often recycled and comes in many different colors, often mixed colors. If you want to denigrate it as used pillow, we can't help you. It's perfectly clean, but the fact remains that it is a better packaging material than polystyrene "popcorn peanuts" or paper as both of these crush and do not rebound. All the packages arrived super fast. Nothing was broken. And the only problem here was the buyer complained about the postage he was already quoted before he bid. He demanded a refund on multiple occasions. This whole charade is nothing more than an extortionist review to force a refund of postage so this buyer can turn around and make more money and when he resells the toys. This buyer is among the worst on the platform, lessens the platform and hurts the community. If I could I'd post the buyers messages for everyone to see.

Steven Berkeley, CA
Dec 09, 2023
Good experience
Auction process was smooth, item was carefully packed and shipped and was described in the auction catalogue. Shipping was reasonably priced.

ArtElizabethtown, NC
Nov 06, 2023

GeorgeNew York, NY
Nov 05, 2023
Pleased with Purchase
Very pleased with the globe I bought, and that the auction house conveniently packed and shipped it to me.

DavidNew Fairfield, CT
Nov 05, 2023

MichaelVenice, FL
Jul 10, 2023
Didn’t return shipping quote. Shipping costs and package way overkill. Cost way to much!!!
Watch your shipping cost with this auction house!!!
Bonanza AuctionsMay 08, 2024
"Didn't return a shipping quote", but some how managed to wrap and ship in house for the buyer? Seems factually inaccurate. "Package way overkill" seems to imply the packaging was great and the item couldn't possibly get broken. Sounds like this buyer didn't actually review the listing where the shipping was, * shockingly looks at notes * prequoted before he bid !). Listen folks, we ship fast, we ship well. If you don't want to be waiting 2 months for your item to show up and you actually want it to show up, unbroken, we're your guy. We don't like games where the auction house pawns your item on some random shipper. We don't like people waiting weeks for those guys to ship and we don't like the mystery of shipping quotes after you bid. That's why we pre-specify the shipping price ahead of time for everyone to view before they bid and personally handle everything in house. Thats about the best service you could ask for. And did we say fast shipping?
JordanWaxhaw, NC
Jul 01, 2023

ShannonMontesano, WA
Jun 25, 2023
Great experience
We purchased two larger items and we were from out of state. Bonanza Auctions was responsive and helpful when I asked about how to work this out with my private shipper not being able to get there within the week. They arrived here as expected and we are thrilled with this purchase. Thank you!

AndrewSt Charles, MO
Jun 25, 2023

LeeOlathe, KS
Jun 16, 2023
Great Auction, reasonable shipping
Bonanza Auctions was easy to work with. I reached out for a shipping quote and it was reasonable. The auction went smoothly. Within one day I received an invoice, then soon after one for shipping and the price was exactly what was quoted. They were responsive via email and responded to most of my communication within a day. When there was a short delay in completing my transaction they did a great job of customer care and made sure I was satisfied with my transaction. I look forward to another Bonanza Auction.

KevinRamsey, NJ
May 21, 2023
Item could have been packed a little tighter.
K
Bonanza AuctionsMay 21, 2023
Thank you. We take great pride in making sure each package will arrive undamaged. Utilizing large boxes and large amounts of packing materials ensures safe delivery. If our greatest flaw is using too large of a box and too much packaging we are doing a good job. We would rather be overzealous than using a smaller, tighter box as that would risk damage.
JohnNorth Middlesex, VT
May 21, 2023
they do not communicate
This was a terrible experience! The 1st invoice billed shipping at more than twice a reasonable amount. It took 4 tries to get it corrected. They do not answer the phone, the voice mail is always full. The items arrived in beat box wrapped in used scrubs and raw insulation
Bonanza AuctionsMay 21, 2023
Your items were wrapped and then packed with synthetic poly fill which is the same thing in bed pillows. It is one of the highest quality packaging materials that can be used. It is much better than packing peanuts or paper and cushions just as a pillow because that is what it is actually used for. Please review that Raw insulation is PINK and made of FIBERGLASS. You can see it at home depot. If you touch it, your skin gets itchy. If you noticed your skin was NOT itchy. It was NOT raw insulation. Also your item was not wrapped in used scrubs. It is completely inappropriate that you make things up. Also your "4 tries" over a short period is also dishonest and misleading to other bidders. Your items were shipped immediately. You got exactly what was shown the pictures. Lightning fast shipping. World class packaging to prevent damage. Your items were in hand less than 2 weeks from auction close and the only reason it was that slow was your dallying on payment. All emails were answered and everything was delivered as promised in an unbelievably fast manner. We have sold over 51, 000 items. We know what we are doing. It is unfortunate we have to put up with situations such as this.
JuanHialeah, FL
May 12, 2023
Very Happy
I contacted them with a concern about shipping and they got back to me right away! Received exactly what they described, actually it was better in person! Great packing, and fast shipping. Would definitely buy again. Great job!
TOP


