Potter & Potter Auctions, IL - Read over 616 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Potter & Potter Auctions (616)

badge TOP RATED
4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 616 Reviews

Charles
Miami Lakes, FL

Apr 04, 2026
CALLAHAN, Harry (American, 1912-1999). Eleanor and Barbara, Chicago. 1954.

Guillermo
Miami, FL

Apr 02, 2026
no, it was good
Thank you, good service
Report
Two Magic Lanterns and 50 Glass Slides. / J. F. (Johann Falk) Magic Lantern. German Made and E.P. (E

Dean
Palm Harbor, FL

Mar 25, 2026
Perfect
Everything went as expected and fast shipping, thanks
Report
Group of Color Photographs of Contortionists. [U.S], Late 20th Century

Inna
Viimsi, EE

Mar 15, 2026
Overall I'm happy with the purchase, but...
Overall I'm happy with the purchase, but the description didn't mention that the doll, which was made in the 1860s, had its head torn off from its body.
Report
German 9” Paper Doll. Germany, ca. 1860s. Heavy cardboard d...

owen
Hefei, CN

Mar 12, 2026
Lawrence & Cohen playing cards. New York, ca. 1863. 51/52 (...

Fred
Buffalo, NY

Mar 12, 2026
Four Square Tangram Sets. Includes: a seven-piece engraved ...

Brandie
Knoxville, TN

Mar 12, 2026
[FORTUNE TELLING]. Group of 5 decks. Including: Prof. Sewar...

Connie
Petal, MS

Feb 27, 2026
[KENNEDY, Robert F.]. Pair of campaign broadsides. 1968. Tw...

Tom
Columbus, IN

Feb 26, 2026
G.A.R. 31st National Encampment 1897 Delegate Pin. Gilt ena...

Andrew
South Milwaukee, WI

Feb 26, 2026
Very understanding of having a friend pick up my lot for me.
Professional in every way and very accomodating.
Report
[CIVIL WAR]. Group of approximately 75 Civil War history ti...

Dan
Franklin, TN

Feb 26, 2026
[CIVIL WAR]. Collection of 37 magic lantern slides. Circa 1...

Mourad
Saint-jean-sur-richelieu, CA

Feb 16, 2026
[WORLD WAR I]. French broadside announcing armistice ending...

Julia
North Bay Village, FL

Jan 08, 2026
Love my new pieces, communication was excellent.
I would bid on pieces from this seller again.
Report
FAIREY, Shepard (American, b. 1970). Two works. Sarah and O...

kristen
Pikesville, MD

Dec 27, 2025
Spaulding & Rogers Mfg. Tattoo Supply catalog. Vorheesville...

Srdjan
Winthrop, MA

Dec 25, 2025
YOUNG, Purvis (American, 1943 – 2010). Untitled (Martin Luther King Poster).

James
Norridge, IL

Dec 24, 2025
PILETTI, Arturo (Italian, 1922 – 1988). Mask with Horn. Sig...

Susan
Chantilly, VA

Dec 24, 2025
Large and Small Sailboat in a Diorama. 20th Century. Mixed ...

AB1 MANAGMENT LLC
Cooper City, FL

Dec 15, 2025
[WESTERN AMERICANA]. DYKES, Jeff. Fifty Great Western Illus...

QZAO
Renfrewshire, GB

Dec 15, 2025
The auction house sent the wrong address and the item was lost without a refund
Lot 0380 HAN Ping Chien (1891 – 1930). Signed Giant RPPC Portrait Lot 0414 KELLAR, Harry and Ching Ling Foo. Portrait of Kellar I successfully auctioned two items on June 21st, Then I paid the auction house through the LiveAuctioneers platform, And leave the correct shipping address. The auction house did not verify the address, and the item was sent to the wrong address, resulting in the loss of the item, At first, the auction house said they would contact the federal government to apply for compensation, but the federal government would not compensate them, Then they said they wanted to refund me, saying it would take 3-5 days to reach my account, I bought the item on June 21st, and I have no errors in this matter, and I have not received any refund, I have been in contact with the auction house for over 3 months regarding the claim, The auction house did not give me any response, resulting in me losing over $1800. This is fraud, and the auction house has no credibility to speak of, Don't buy things from his family. If there are problems, they won't help you deal with them, they will only delay the process, If you encounter problems with the items you purchased from his home, you can only accept your misfortune. I hope my comment can help more people
Report
HAN Ping Chien (1891 – 1930). Signed Giant RPPC Portrait of...

Stephen
Huntington Beach, CA

Dec 04, 2025
I deal with 200 auction houses and Potter is the best. They grade well and respond quickly
I deal with 200 auction houses and Potter might be the best of any of them. They grade well, respond quickly and do shipping in-house. Their auction items are original and they have great variety with many unique items.
Report
Pink Floyd / Three Rivers Stadium. 1975. Pacific Presentati...

Mike
Carmel By The Sea, CA

Oct 30, 2025
Odd fellows auction AAA + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
Great t o have a auction house that packs and ships AAA + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
Report
[FOLK ART]. Heart in Hand Carved Staff. 20th Century. Charm...

Richard
Maspeth, NY

Oct 30, 2025
Modern Woodmen of America Banner. (M.W.A.) Circa 1900. Hand...

James
Crested Butte, CO

Oct 30, 2025
Masonic 14th Degree Carved Hand Staff. Circa 1880s. Painted...

Ralph
Apple Valley, CA

Oct 21, 2025
a first class auction house.
I would enjoy every time I worked with Potter and Potter.
Report
Group of 6 Manuscript Hospital Supervisor’s Night Report No...

Greg
Waterford, MI

Oct 20, 2025
Oval dynamometer with scale. Paris: Mathieu, mid-19th centu...

Jeff
Glen Burnie, MD

Oct 19, 2025
Great auction house
Everything from responsiveness to quality of items sold, shipping and professionalism was top notch!
Report
Plaster Cast of Big Foot / Sasquatch Footprint. White plast...

Tom
Houston, TX

Oct 19, 2025
Auction
Everything great
Report
[FEMINISM & LESBIAN ACTIVISM]. Group of photographs of pro-...

Michael
Key Largo, FL

Oct 11, 2025
Fast and easy
Fast and easy thank you
Report
Standard Oil Red Crown. Single-sided porcelain (SSP) gas pu...

Jeff
Kings Mountain, NC

Sep 18, 2025
Best shipping prices!!
This is one of the best auctions we have bought from. Did not over charge on shipping and most auctions kill you on shipping. Boxed and packed 3 lance jars and shipping was only 50 $items arrived well packed and very clean. I will buy from them again!!
Report
Group of Four Lance Products Including Three Jars and a Met...

Chris
Albemarle, NC

Sep 18, 2025
Great service. Fast shipping.
Great service. Fast shipping. Accurate description
Report
Pair of Drink Coca-Cola Trays with Soda Jerks. Coshocton, O...

raymond
Orange, CA

Sep 18, 2025
VERY KNOWLEGABLE AND PROFESSIONAL STAFF
very responsive to our questions and needs
Report
Disneyland Cigarette Smoking Stand. Disneyland, ca. 1970s. ...

STEPHAN
Wheaton, IL

Sep 18, 2025
D. Gottlieb & Co. Pro-Football 25 Cent Pinball Machine. Chi...

Steven
Forest, VA

Sep 18, 2025
Planter’s Salted Peanuts 5 Cent Counter Display Jar. Clear ...

mike
Seattle, WA

Sep 11, 2025
[SUGAÏ, Kumi (1919-1996), artist]. TARN, Nathaniel (1928-20...

Kevin
Muscatine, IA

Sep 10, 2025
[AMERICANA]. McKENNEY, Thomas L. (1785-1859) and James HALL...

Paul
Warminster, PA

Sep 05, 2025
Potter & Potter. A Top Shelf Auction House in every Regard!
I am very pleased with every aspect of my purchase from Potter & Potter! From the listing photos and description, the communication, the live bidding, the billing and the easy shipping experience! I will follow their auctions and recomend them to anyone!
Report
Hand-carved Circus Wagon Figurehead. Circa early 20th centu...

Elizabeth
Aiken, SC

Aug 17, 2025
[FORE-EDGE PAINTING]. The Acts of the Days of the Son of Ma...

Ross
Worcester, MA

Aug 16, 2025
Great experience
Charges are transparent, shipping was very professional, bidding was easy.
Report
R. Crumb Mr. Natural Does the Dishes Limited Edition Signed...

Jeremy
Lexington, KY

Aug 14, 2025
Easy to buy from.
I purchased one historical book. Check out was easy, shipping was very fair and well done. The box it was in could have gotten soaked and the book would have still been fine. I would highly recommend Potter & Potter Auctions.
Report
[CIVIL WAR]. YOUNG, Bennett H. (1843-1919). History of the ...

Alan
Nashville, TN

Aug 14, 2025
CLANCY, Tom (1947-2013). The Hunt for Red October. Annapoli...

Scott
Hewlett, NY

Aug 02, 2025
honesty and truthfully depicted
they handled all questions and thoughts as if i were a regular participant —-first time and very easy go to!!
Report
The Grateful Dead / Tulsa Fairground Pavilion. 1979. First ...

ray
Sicklerville, NJ

Aug 01, 2025
Hartland Washington Redskins Football Figure. Circa 1958-60...

Jennifer
Woodbridge, VA

Jul 31, 2025
Large Collection of Hollywood Golden Age Snapshots. Circa 1...

Marco
Maywood, NJ

Jul 31, 2025
Reliable on shipping without being over charged
Nice job during the auction no issues
Report
Single Series Tarzan #20. United Features Syndicate, 1940. ...

Phil
Davenport, FL

Jul 01, 2025
[SIDESHOW BANNERS] BARNETT, P. Hoo La La. (Hula Show). Not ...

Kerry
Clarkston, GA

Jun 27, 2025
FARROW, William Mcknight (American, 1885-1967). Christmas E...

Robert
Brazil, IN

Jun 26, 2025
Fees and Shipping extremely
Most auctions houses charge ridiculous shipping fees. I was shocked how reasonable. Compared to my previous purchases. I would definitely purchase from again! Thank you...
Report
NEES, Gerald (American, b. 1938). Untitled (Lincoln the Law...

Edward
Chicago, IL

Jun 26, 2025
GRUTZKA, Klaus (American, 1923-2011). Peter A. B. Widener. ...

Del
Concord, NC

Jun 26, 2025
STEICHEN, Edward (American, 1879-1973). Self Portrait of St...

Jeffery
Desert Hot Springs, CA

Jun 21, 2025
Five Stars
One of the most professional auction houses I buy from!
Report
Hagenbeck-Wallace Circus / Military Maids. Erie Litho, ca. ...