Bidder Reviews for Thomaston Place Auction Galleries (434)
4.4 out of 5.0 Stars
1-50 of 434 Reviews
ThomasMidland, TX
Mar 27, 2026
In House Shipping
Only negative was the in house shipping. Although the packing was great it was easily 3 times the price what it should have been and took 3-4 weeks to ship out. Good auction to deal with i would just recommend a UPS store instead of the in house shipping
ChrisWarsaw, OH
Mar 25, 2026
Great Auction House
Item arrived yesterday afternoon, just as described in auction! Nice Piece! Packaged extremely secure!! Shipped very quickly! Great Experience! Very reasonable priced Auction House! Would definitely participate in another Auction! THANK YOU SO MUCH!
DavidBay City, MI
Mar 14, 2026
Excellent Recommended Shipper
Bought a wonderful bronze and it was my first time working with Thomaston Place. It was a very good experience and everything was as pictured and accurately described.
EugeneDallastown, PA
Mar 14, 2026
Great experience.
Love the silver marriage chest, also very fast and quality shipping, well pleased. Thank you.!!!
DouglasChecotah, OK
Mar 14, 2026
LauraReadfield, ME
Mar 13, 2026
Flexible and responsive!
The team was very knowledgeable and flexible around my pick up schedule. I look forward to working with them again!
AlvahBerlin, VT
Mar 06, 2026
Fabulous Service
I had never purchased an item from Thomaston Place Auction before and needed help with the shipping. A representative by the name I believe was Allan was so helpful. He was very knowledgeable and friendly. He made the experience a very positive one. I will purchase again because of the fabulous service.
HeatherPeachtree City, GA
Jan 22, 2026
NicholasOverland Park, KS
Jan 19, 2026

SherilynFort Worth, TX
Dec 17, 2025
These people are sketchy!!!
Will never NEVER NEVER bid at this house again. I have several complaints, 1st my Crock I bought for 1400.00 has a hairline crack along the bottom they did not disclose nor showed the bottom in pics. I also had them slip one higher bid in on me on a dresser I was winning I placed another bid immediately they did not accept and closed auction quick as blink! Then would not return several of my calls. There are other complaints about their practice with Better Business Bureau along this same line. UN-TRUST WORTHY! Crooks!
JohnBell Buckle, TN
Dec 08, 2025
MichaelSan Diego, CA
Nov 30, 2025
RonRensselaer, NY
Nov 30, 2025
AnneNewburyport, Ma, MA
Nov 30, 2025
Mary JoEdenton, NC
Nov 30, 2025
MichaelJackson Heights, NY
Nov 22, 2025
Thank you!
What a wonderful Auction House to deal with. Without question, the process after auction to pack and send went smoothly. I love an auction house that handles everything, from ship to stern. thank you again!
MichaelRockfall, CT
Oct 14, 2025

RandallMt Prospect, IL
Oct 10, 2025

JeffSeattle, WA
Oct 07, 2025
Reputable Auction House. Superior service!
An amazing experience. Auctioneer responded promptly and provided additional photos that I requested. Responded with detail information. Packed items with care and shipping was super fast. The best of auction houses!

KenSonora, CA
Oct 06, 2025
KanPlano, TX
Oct 04, 2025
Fake ivory product
The Japanese lady with child was listed as ivory. But it is anything but ivory. My friend looked carefully. He thought this was resin. Contacted auction house. They required an expert certification before refund. To get an expert certification will probably cost more than the item's price.

MichaelWest Hartford, CT
Oct 02, 2025
Great experience!
Excellent item, as described. Item was expertly packaged, and in-house shipping charges were very reasonable.

MarcBar Harbor, ME
Sep 24, 2025
One of the highlights of the Maine auction "scene".
One of the highlights of the Maine auction "scene". Thank You all.

ShawnRockport, UM
Sep 21, 2025
Nice people
Very knowledgeable very nice people when you go there they wanna help you just a group of nice people very satisfied with the products that we bought thank everyone there Shawn Rockport, Maine

DanielMarana, AZ
Sep 20, 2025

James Mussallem Treasures LLCJacksonville, FL
Sep 18, 2025

ChrisWest Palm Beach, FL
Sep 10, 2025
Item not as described, and did not rectify
Decanter I purchased was a “marriage.” The stopper did not match the decanter even though the description implied it was all original. The proof was in the etching on the decanter and stopper which did not match. I had to contact them numerous times and eventually got somebody secondary, who said they would speak to the supervisor and get back to me, but didn’t think they would do anything which in fact, they never got back to me or did anything. So very disappointing especially from a repeat customer. This will be my last purchase from this auction house.
DanielBoston, MA
Aug 14, 2025

JMW GalleryCambridge, MA
Jul 23, 2025
MichaelOscoda, MI
Jul 21, 2025

Charles E.Topsham, ME
Jul 21, 2025
Kevin Muscatine, IA
Jul 20, 2025
DebbieElm Mott, TX
Jul 19, 2025
Shipping was outrageous
I liked the items, but the shipping was way too much. They told me the shipping would be about $90, but they charged me $175 instead. I complained about it, and they took off $10. Took weeks to get here, too. Not sure how much longer I will be bidding with shipping becoming so ridiculous. Cheaper to buy on ebay. Shipping is cheap, items arrive fast, and no high premiums, like almost 30 % in some cases. Sad.

RobertWilloughby, OH
Jul 19, 2025
Misdescribed lot, broken item, no response
Bought a lot of toys for a specific item. When I unpacked I noted the one cast iron had been broken, drilled and wired together. This was not disclosed in description, and did show in their one photo of the lot. I sent two emails asking to discuss this matter with no response. I’m done dealing with Auction Houses who mislead descriptions and have no customer service.

MelvinFrisco, TX
Jun 11, 2025
Post auction support is superior to most other auction houses with which I have dealt.
The descriptions and photos are accurate. Additional information is provided promptly and accurately. What is outstanding and noteworthy is the post auction support that this house provides. Communications are open, honest, timely and straight forward. Issue resolution is rapid and done with a high degree of professionalism. All staff were extremely helpful and responsive. I will be adding this house to sites that I visit in the future. Impressive.

fj Oneonta, AL
May 23, 2025

DanielBoston, MA
May 11, 2025

KirstenAlexandria, VA
Mar 29, 2025

BradWinter Haven, FL
Mar 19, 2025

AnneNewburyport, Ma, MA
Mar 16, 2025
LynnAustin, TX
Mar 15, 2025

TerryOcala, FL
Mar 07, 2025
Shipping way to expensive
Shipping is way to expensive. To expensive to ship two coins. only costs $4.85 via USPS and the packaging no more than $2.

CarlRidgewood, NJ
Feb 13, 2025
Poor support with shipping
Auction house did not have good customer support for shipping etc Listed some local providers who were non responsive... took over a month to finally get product with no help from Auction house Would no use again.
MichaelDelta, CA
Feb 10, 2025

CharlesLavon, TX
Feb 07, 2025
Responsive and Professional Customer Service
I bought numismatic coins from Thomaston Place. I live in Texas and was charged sales tax which is not required from Texas. Thomaston was responsive and helpful getting resolved.

PatrickSpring, TX
Dec 04, 2024
StuartToronto, CA
Dec 04, 2024
Great Service
Very fast service and the painting arrived safely. Thanks. It looks great

Thomaston Place Auction GalleriesDec 06, 2024
Thank you for sharing your experience! We're glad you joined us for the auction and that you love your painting! Hope to see you at the next auction!

TOP


