Key Date Coins, NJ - Read over 885 Reviews from Customers
LiveAuctioneers Logo

Bidder Reviews for Key Date Coins (885)

badge TOP RATED
4.5 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

200-250 of 885 Reviews

All Ratings
Highest Rated

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Sep 18, 2023
1905-1912 (1905 Issue) Imperial Russia 3 Rubles Banknote P# 9b, Sig. Konshin Grades vf details

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Sep 18, 2023
1920 Germany 10 Mark Note P# 67A Grades vf, very fine

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Sep 18, 2023
1922 Germany 50,000 Mark Note P# 79 Grades vf+

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Sep 18, 2023
Exceptional
I’ve purchased quite a few coins and currency from Key Date Coins, and I have to say. These guys at KDC are very good at what they do. The last coins I purchased were nicer than they had expressed. I’m very very happy with the coins I received From Key Date Coins and will buy many more from them in the time to come. Exceptional customer service exceptional coins. Additionally Key Date Coins Has one of the Most Entertaining Auctions I Have Ever Attended With Live Audio and Video The Entire Time.
Report
1942 Great Britain 3 Pence KM: 848 Grades Select AU

Mackenzie
Calgary, CA

Sep 17, 2023
100 % misleading descriptions
Do not trust anything this auction house says in their descriptions. Direct quote from description: “Each page will contain silver coins”. I purchased 11 pages and not a single silver coin was received. Why blatantly lie? Why not just label the coins for what they are?
Report
Huge Liifetime Collection - Too Many Coins To Auction Individually - This Lot is For One Page of 20

David
La Crosse, WI

Sep 13, 2023
Mixed small cents 1c orig shotgun roll, 1920 Lincoln Cent, Wheat Cent other end, Coca-Cola Brandt

Robert
Oregon City, OR

Sep 13, 2023
Mixed small cents 1c orig shotgun roll, 1896 Indian Cent, Wheat Cent other end, Coca-Cola Brandt

Robert
Oregon City, OR

Sep 13, 2023
2011 Mint Proof Set In Original Case! 14 Coins Inside!

Robert
Oregon City, OR

Sep 13, 2023
2009 United States Mint Proof Set - 18 Pieces!

Kristie
Las Vegas, NV

Sep 11, 2023
1953 $2 Red Seal United States Note Grades Select AU

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Sep 11, 2023
1912-1917 (1909 Issue) Imperial Russia 5 Rubles Banknote P# 10b, Sig. Shipov Grades Choice AU/BU

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Sep 11, 2023
PCGS 1945-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Graded ms66 by PCGS

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Sep 11, 2023
1919 Austria 1,000 Kronen Note P: 59 Grades Choice AU/BU Slider

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Sep 11, 2023
1923 Weimar Germany 10 Millionen Mark Note P# 106C Grades vf++

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Sep 11, 2023
1912-1917 (1905 Issue) Imperial Russia 3 Rubles Banknote P# 9c, Sig. Shipov Grades vf+

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Sep 11, 2023
1917 Imperial Germnay 5 Mark Note P# 56B Grades vf++

Henry
Sturgeon Bay, WI

Sep 04, 2023
1999 Painted Eagle Silver Eagle Dollar $1

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Sep 04, 2023
1976 $2 Green Seal Federal Reserve Note Grades Gem CU

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Sep 04, 2023
1972 Great Britian 10 New Pence Military Payment Note P: M45A Grades Gem CU

Doug
Smyrna, TN

Sep 04, 2023
1787 Connecticut Colonial Cent 1c Grades vg details

Stephen
Rancho Cucamonga, CA

Aug 31, 2023
Check your Orders for accuracy.
I have made many purchases from Key Date Coins and have been mostly happy with my purchases. However on this and another order there were missing and/or incorrect items received. I have messaged Key Date Coins multiple times and have yet to receive any response.
Report
1996 United States Mint Set in Original Government Packaging, 11 Coins Inside!

Kasey
Calgary, CA

Aug 29, 2023
1973 Canada 1 Dollar Note P# 85A Grades vf+

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Aug 28, 2023
1957 (2500) Thailand 10 Satang Y# 79 Grades xf

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Aug 28, 2023
1929 $5 National Currency 'The Chase National Bank Of The City Of New York NY' Type I Grades vf+

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Aug 28, 2023
1963B $1 'Barr Note' Federal Reserve Note Grades Choice AU

Stephen
Rancho Cucamonga, CA

Aug 25, 2023
Check your orders!
I have had many great experiences with Key Date Coins. However, in recent weeks, I have had problems with my orders, I did not receive the item that was advertised. In the first instance, Key Date came through immediately and sent me the correct item. However, recently there have been two instances where I did not receive the item advertised and multiple messages and emails to them have gone ignored.
Report
Huge Liifetime Collection - Too Many Coins To Auction Individually - This Lot is For One Page of 20

Kristie
Las Vegas, NV

Aug 25, 2023
Easy way to jump into coin collecting
KDC usually has the same items from day to day so if you miss an item due to a higher bid, the item will usually come up again and you can try again. Most of their stuff is not super rare and pricing reflects that. It's a fun way to get your feet wet.
Report
2007 United States Mint Proof Set - 14 Piece set

Ryan
Huntington Beach, CA

Aug 24, 2023
Deceptive, big surcharges, weeks to receive, and unresponsive to emails.
Deceptive, big surcharges, weeks to receive packages, and unresponsive to concerns, such as not receiving the item purchased. I see other customers have had similar bad experiences with KDC.
Report
2006 New Zealand 20 Cents KM# 118 Grades GEM++ Unc

Deneen
Lake Elsinore, CA

Aug 23, 2023
Picture did not match description
I had been bidding on the different large collection lots and looked carefully at the pictures. I had purchased 100s of dollars of these. Suddenly, the picture shown for the item I was bidding on was NOT what was described at all. Totally different item. I reached out to info@ kdc but no response. No more key date coins
Report
1981 United States Mint Proof Set 6 coins

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Aug 22, 2023
1963B $1 'Barr Note' Federal Reserve Note Grades xf+

John
Buckeye, AZ

Aug 22, 2023
Key Date-Good house
Key Date-Good house
Report
***Auction Highlight*** 1938-p Jefferson Nickel Near TOP POP! 5c Graded ms67+ 5fs By SEGS (fc)

John
Buckeye, AZ

Aug 22, 2023
Key Date-Good house
Key Date-Good house
Report
***Auction Highlight*** 1955-p Lincoln Cent Near TOP POP! 1c Graded ms67 rd BY SEGS (fc)

John
Buckeye, AZ

Aug 22, 2023
Key Date-Good house
Key Date-Good house
Report
1944-d Lincoln Cent 1c Grades GEM+ Unc RB

John
Buckeye, AZ

Aug 22, 2023
Key Date-Good house
Key Date-Good house
Report
1942-p Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ 5fs

John
Buckeye, AZ

Aug 22, 2023
Key Date-Good house
Key Date-Good house
Report
1944-p Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM 5fs

John
Buckeye, AZ

Aug 22, 2023
Key Date-Good house
Key Date-Good house
Report
1944-p Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ 5fs

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Aug 21, 2023
1922 Germany (Weimar Republic) 500 Marks Banknote P# 74b Grades vf++

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Aug 21, 2023
1955 Portugal 50 Centavos KM-577 Grades vf++.

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Aug 21, 2023
1917 France 1 Franc KM-844.1 Grades vf+

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Aug 21, 2023
1942-p Washington Quarter 25c Grades GEM+ Unc

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Aug 21, 2023
1970 Western Samoa One Tala $1. Commemorative James Cook Coin. KM# 9

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Aug 21, 2023
1995 $1 Federal Reserve Note Grades Gem+ CU

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Aug 21, 2023
1963 $1 Green Seal Federal Reserve Note (Philadelphia, PA) Grades Select CU

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Aug 21, 2023
1923 Fifth Issue Germany 10 Million Mark Post-WWI Hyperinflation Banknote P# 106a, Watermark: G/D in

matt
Philadelphia, PA

Aug 21, 2023
1923-s Lincoln Cent 1c Grades f+

william
Ocala, FL

Aug 21, 2023
Key Date Coin's Deceptive Practices
I purchased a mint set based on the provided description. It caught my attention and was the only reason I purchased it. Upon receipt of the set I examined it, only to find that it was not as advertised. I contacted Key Date about returning it because of the price paid for something worth much less. I was told to return it for a refund. Key Date received it on June 12, and has yet to take my calls or emails. If I am one incident, imagine the possibilities of multiple non payments. They used the postal service to facilitate this deception. That is not a good process to be involved in. I have gone to a third party who is involved with them, and guess what??? Even they don't get a response. Watch your money!!!
Report
1918-d Buffalo Nickel 5c Grades g, good

Kristie
Las Vegas, NV

Aug 18, 2023
You can get your feet wet with coin collecting without spending a fortune.
The auction house offers coins at a price point that a beginning collector can afford. They do offer some real gems but often times it's more common coins that many would still like to have in their collection.
Report
1984 United States Mint Set in Original Government Packaging, 10 Coins Inside

Richard
Birdsboro, PA

Aug 18, 2023
1968 United States Mint Proof Set 5 coins

Margaretta
Richmond, TX

Aug 17, 2023
Customer service is terrible
Never returned my messages. Late getting my bills.
Report
1953 $2 Red Seal United States Note Fr-1509 Grades vf+

Doug
Georgetown, TX

Aug 16, 2023
1957 Mexico 5 Pesos Silver KM# 469 Grades Choice Unc
View:
50
TOP