Sold2016Peyton Manning Rookie Card & Insert Lot (6)Peyton Manning Rookie Card & Insert Lot (6) 1998 Bowman Chrome Preview, 1998 Black Diamond, 1998 Collectors Edge Nrmt-Mint ConditionSee Sold Price
Sold2021Lot of 2 Peyton Manning Football CardsLot of 2 Peyton Manning Football Cards. 1998 upper deck rookie. Super powers insert #516,Nmt. 1999 upper deck Ionix #25 Nm MtSee Sold Price
Sold20201998 UD Choice Starquest Rookquest Insert Card - Peyton1998 UD Choice Starquest Rookquest Insert Card - Peyton Manning (Rookie Year) & John Elway SR01See Sold Price
Sold2017Football card lot with rookies Peyton ManningFootball card lot with rookies Peyton ManningSee Sold Price
Sold2016Peyton Manning Rookie, Insert and LE Cards (10)Peyton Manning rookie, insert and limited edition football cards (10).See Sold Price
Sold20161998 TWO FLEER 201 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE CARDS1998 TWO FLEER 201 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE CARDS Two Fleer Peyton Manning cards, from Series 201 1998. Shipping / Pickup: We Can Ship This Item Lot Location: #1 - Manor's GallerySee Sold Price
Sold20231998 Topps Certified A10 Bronze Peyton Manning Signed Rookie Card (SGC 9)Autographed 1998 Topps Certified #A10 Bronze Peyton Manning NFL Football Trading Card (Rookie Card) (SGC 9). Peyton Manning undoubtedly needs to be in the conversation regarding the greatest quarterbaSee Sold Price
Sold2019Rookie Cards and Insert Cards (10)Ten rookie cards and insert cards. Roger Clemens, Peyton Manning, Derek Jeter and more. NM/NM-MT or better. Condition report is provided as a courtesy and is only an opinion. This condition report isSee Sold Price
Sold2021GROUP LOT OF FOOTBALL CARDS SMITH, MANNING, ELWAY(11) INCLUDING: SIX 1976 WONDER BREAD ALL-STARS. EMMITT SMITH TOPPS ROOKIE CARD, JOHN ELWAY TOPPS ROOKIE CARD, PEYTON MANNING AURORA CHAMPIONSHIP FEVER AND MORESee Sold Price
Sold201731 card football lot with rookies stars Hall ofFamer's and more really nice lot Reggie Bush Peyton Manning Johnny Unitas Brett Favre Frank Gore rookies Ryan Fitz Patrick Mark Sanchez rookies Justin Blackman rookies Darren Sproles rookie DeAngelo WSee Sold Price
Sold2023Lot of (65) Assorted Football Star Player & Rookie Cards - Varying Conditions - Tom Brady, PeytonLot of (65) Assorted Football Star Player & Rookie Cards - Varying Conditions - Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, John ElwaySee Sold Price
Sold2021LOT OF 6 NBA BASKETBALL ROOKIE CARDSNAZ REID HOOPS PREMIUM SILVER LAZER PRIZM, DeANDRE HUNTER NBA DEBUT ROOKIE INSERT, JORDAN POOLE MOSAIC RCSee Sold Price
Sold2021LOT OF 6 NBA ROOKIE BASKETBALL CARDSrj barrett knicks rookie insert, 2020-21 prizm dp jordn nwroaSee Sold Price
Sold2021LOT OF 6 NBA ROOKIE BASKETBALL CARDSGOGA BITADZE RED MOSAIC, CAMERON JOHNSON PRIZM DP, RJ BARRETT HOOPS ROOKIE INSERTSee Sold Price
Sold2022Manning, Marino, Jim Kelly FB Cards with Rookies 9Peyton Manning, Dan Marino, Jim Kelly FB Cards with Rookies (9). Most appear to be NM-MT/MT. If lot is absent of a condition report one may be requested via email. Condition report is provided as an oSee Sold Price
Sold2021LOT OF 6 NBA ROOKIE BASKETBALL CARDSJAYLEN NOWELL PINK CAMO, RJ BARRETT AND JARRETT CULVER BLUE CHIPS ROOKIE INSERTSSee Sold Price
Sold2017Peyton Manning Johnny Unitas three card lot upperdeck highlights insert zone highlights insert MVP contenders Andrew luck/199 called heroes Johnny Unitas Peyton ManningSee Sold Price
Sold2021Lot of Great Sports Cards - mostly all stars includingLot of Great Sports Cards - mostly all stars including David Robinson, Lots of Joe Montana, Jose Canseco, Derek Jeter (including rookie), Barry Bonds, Robinson Cano, Peyton Manning, Jim Thome Manny RaSee Sold Price
Sold2022Mixed Lots of 10 Top Loaded Sport CardsPeyton Manning 2005 Topps 50th Anniversary League Leaders Indianapolis Colts 318Peyton Manning 2014 Topps Chrome Green Refractor 42 BroncosConnor Scott Bowmans Best Auto Prospect Refractor Rookie #B18See Sold Price
Sold20202019 ROOKIES AND STARS SERIAL NUMBERED LOTPEYTON MANNING CRUSADE 40/75, DREW BREES "GREAT AMERICAN HEROS INSERT 28/35See Sold Price
May 23South Florida Auction & Estate Sale Services IncGem Mint 10 PEYTON MANNING Rookie Football CardUS$18(2 bids)
May 23South Florida Auction & Estate Sale Services IncGem Mint 10 PEYTON MANNING Rookie Football CardUS$6
6 days LeftPacific Global AuctionGraded 1998 Upper Deck UD Choice Peyton Manning #193 Rookie RC Card PSA 10 MintUS$200
7 days LeftGolden Air Auctionsgraded 1998 score peyton manning #233 rookie RC football card PSA 9 mintUS$110
4 days LeftGolden Gate Auctioneergraded 1998 collector's edge peyton manning #135 1st place rookie card PSA 10US$200
May 22Golden Air AuctionsGraded 1998 Stadium Club Peyton Manning #195 Rookie RC Football Card PSA 10 MintUS$400
3 days LeftGolden Air Auctionspeyton manning autographed 1998 topps chrome rookie card colts PSA/DNA #41457327US$1,100
6 days LeftGolden Air AuctionsPEYTON MANNING SIGNED 1998 TOPPS CHROME ROOKIE CARD #165 AUTO COLTS RC PSA/DNAUS$1,475
5 days LeftGolden Gate Auctioneerpeyton manning 1998 ce supreme gold ingot rookie card- SGC graded 4 vg-exUS$78
2 days LeftGolden Air AuctionsPeyton Manning 1998 Upper Deck SPX Finite Rookie Card- Beckett/BGS Graded 7.5 NMUS$150
1064 Lots AwayMynt Auctions2014 Panini Certified Materials Mirror Red #MPM Peyton Manning Card PSA NM MT 8US$10
22 hrs LeftMynt Auctions2011 Panini Prestige #88 Peyton Manning Signed Card PSA Slabbed ColtsUS$10(1 bid)
May 25Caff's Collectibles1978 Topps NFL Football Rookies Stars Partial Starter Set Lot Cards 362/528 Excellent ConditionUS$10(1 bid)
May 25Caff's Collectibles1979 Topps NFL Football Rookies Stars Partial Starter Set Lot Cards 352/528 Excellent ConditionUS$15(1 bid)
May 25Caff's Collectibles2023 Topps Rookie Resolution Black & White Complete 10 Baseball Card Insert SetUS$10
May 30Ripley AuctionsLot of 3 1990's Rookie Basketball Cards, McGrady, Nowitzki, Iverson PSA GradedUS$10
50 mins LeftMynt AuctionsPeyton Manning NFL Debut Original Full Ticket Sep 6 1998 PSA 6 Pop 4!US$4,400
3 days LeftMynt AuctionsPeyton Manning Signed NFL Debut Original Ticket Sep 6 1998 PSA DNA Pop 3!US$8,700
1 day LeftMynt Auctions2004 Topps Finest Refractor #110 Eli Manning Auto RC BGS 10 PRISTINE Pop 4US$2,200