Sports Memorabilia

Payton Manning plaque First Image

#image-loader-main { display: none; }

Payton Manning plaque First Image

Payton Manning plaque

Total Sales1 Sold

Median Sale Price

Sale Price Range

Similar Upcoming Sales

Framed Peyton, Eli & Archie Manning Signed Photos (1 of 6)

Framed Peyton, Eli & Archie Manning Signed Photos

The North Georgia Auction Company LLC

Feb 16, 2026

Peyton Manning Signed Blue Jersey Framed Beckett Denver Broncos (1 of 2)

Peyton Manning Signed Blue Jersey Framed Beckett Denver Broncos

4 days Left

Peyton Manning 1999 Skybox Metal Universe #77 Indianapolis Colts (1 of 2)

Peyton Manning 1999 Skybox Metal Universe #77 Indianapolis Colts

Western Pennsylvania Trading Inc.

Feb 13, 2026

2024 TOPPS COMPOSITE PEYTON MANNING RESURGENCE SIGN-OFF INSERT (1 of 3)

2024 TOPPS COMPOSITE PEYTON MANNING RESURGENCE SIGN-OFF INSERT

Feb 18, 2026

Peyton Manning Rookie Card 1998 Fleer Brilliants #120 Indianapolis Colts (1 of 2)

Peyton Manning Rookie Card 1998 Fleer Brilliants #120 Indianapolis Colts

Western Pennsylvania Trading Inc.

Feb 17, 2026

Peyton Manning Signed Colts Blue Jersey with Fanatics Authentic COA (1 of 4)

Peyton Manning Signed Colts Blue Jersey with Fanatics Authentic COA

3 days Left

Peyton Manning Signed Colts Game Jersey Upper Deck COA (1 of 5)

Peyton Manning Signed Colts Game Jersey Upper Deck COA

4 days Left

2003 Upper Deck #4 Peyton Manning Signed Card PSA Authenticated Colts (1 of 2)

2003 Upper Deck #4 Peyton Manning Signed Card PSA Authenticated Colts

3 days Left

Peyton Manning Strike Force Insert 1999 Upper Deck #SF-11 Indianapolis Colts (1 of 2)

Peyton Manning Strike Force Insert 1999 Upper Deck #SF-11 Indianapolis Colts

Western Pennsylvania Trading Inc.

2 days Left

Peyton Manning Signed Colts Jersey with 8x10 Photo JSA COA (1 of 1)

Peyton Manning Signed Colts Jersey with 8x10 Photo JSA COA

Feb 14, 2026

Peyton Manning Hall of Fame Insert 2025 Panini Mosaic #296 Indianapolis Colts (1 of 2)

Peyton Manning Hall of Fame Insert 2025 Panini Mosaic #296 Indianapolis Colts

Western Pennsylvania Trading Inc.

2 days Left

JOHNNY UNITAS COLTS SIGNED COMMEMORATIVE DISPLAY (1 of 4)

JOHNNY UNITAS COLTS SIGNED COMMEMORATIVE DISPLAY

Antique Arena Inc.

Feb 15, 2026

John Elway Autographed Framed Jersey Denver Broncos Beckett Certified (1 of 2)

John Elway Autographed Framed Jersey Denver Broncos Beckett Certified

1 day Left

AMERICAN FOOTBALL BALTIMORE RAVENS COLLECTIBLE PLAQUE (1 of 4)

AMERICAN FOOTBALL BALTIMORE RAVENS COLLECTIBLE PLAQUE

Antique Arena Inc.

Feb 15, 2026

Peyton Manning Autographed Colts Blue Mitchell & Ness Legacy Jersey With Fanatics COA (1 of 3)

Peyton Manning Autographed Colts Blue Mitchell & Ness Legacy Jersey With Fanatics COA

Feb 13, 2026

Peyton Manning Signed Colts Blue Jersey Action 8x10 Photo with JSA COA (1 of 1)

Peyton Manning Signed Colts Blue Jersey Action 8x10 Photo with JSA COA

Feb 14, 2026

Similar Sale History

Unlock All Prices

Sold

Payton Manning plaque (1 of 1)

Payton Manning plaque Payton Manning plaque

Sold

Payton Manning Colts Presentation Plaque (1 of 1)

Payton Manning Colts Presentation Plaque Official NFL / Steiner 1999 photo of Payton Manning, #18 legendary quarterback for the Indianapolis Colts. Photo is 8\" x 10\". There is also a Manning trading card, and name plate. All are attached t

Sold

PAYTON MANNING SIGNED 2021 HALL OF FAME INDIANAPOLIS COLTS JERSEY (GAA AUTOGRAPH COA) (1 of 1)

PAYTON MANNING SIGNED 2021 HALL OF FAME INDIANAPOLIS COLTS JERSEY (GAA AUTOGRAPH COA)Prices are in Canadian dollars

Sold

PAYTON MANNING SIGNED TOPPS CARD AUTOGRAPH EXPERT UNION COA (1 of 2)

PAYTON MANNING SIGNED TOPPS CARD AUTOGRAPH EXPERT UNION COA Prices are in Canadian dollars

Sold

Payton Manning Signed Card Autograph Expert Union COA (1 of 2)

Payton Manning Signed Card Autograph Expert Union COA Payton Manning Signed Card Autograph Expert Union COAPrices are in Canadian dollars

Sold

Signed Payton Manning Small Helmet in Case (1 of 5)

Signed Payton Manning Small Helmet in Case Signed Payton Manning Small Helmet in Case blue and white miniature Colts Helmet

Sold

Payton Manning Cards. 100 in the lot. (1 of 1)

Payton Manning Cards. 100 in the lot.The lot consists of Rookies, Indy Colts and Tennessee Vols.

Sold

Sports Lot incl Walter Payton Plaque, Zamboni Toy New in Box, Sammy Sosa Plaque (1 of 8)

Sports Lot incl Walter Payton Plaque, Zamboni Toy New in Box, Sammy Sosa Plaque Sports Lot incl Walter Payton Plaque, Chicago Blackhawks Zamboni Toy New in Box, Sammy Sosa Plaque

Sold

Authentic photo of Payton Manning & Ben Roethisberger (1 of 1)

Authentic photo of Payton Manning & Ben Roethisberger Authentic photo of Payton Manning & Ben Roethisberger w/NFL Seal

Sold

PAYTON MANNING SIGNED PANINI MOSAIC CARD NO. 100 (COA PROS COA) (1 of 2)

PAYTON MANNING SIGNED PANINI MOSAIC CARD NO. 100 (COA PROS COA)Prices are in Canadian dollars

Sold

1998 PAYTON MANNING EDGE ODYSSEY ROOKIE CARD (1 of 2)

1998 PAYTON MANNING EDGE ODYSSEY ROOKIE CARD Prices are in Canadian dollars

Sold

Russell Wilson Payton Manning Old School Lot (1 of 1)

Russell Wilson Payton Manning Old School Lot Russell Wilson Payton Manning Old School Lot

Sold

2 Walter Payton Plaques (1 of 6)

2 Walter Payton Plaques 2 Walter Payton Plaques

Sold

3 Signed Indianapolis Colts Riddell Mini Helmets (1 of 4)

3 Signed Indianapolis Colts Riddell Mini Helmets 3 signed Indianapolis Colts Riddell mini helmets including Payton Manning

Sold

Box of assorted trading cards. (1 of 6)

Box of assorted trading cards.This is a box of mixed trading cards. It includes some of the biggest names in Football, Basketball, and Baseball. Sold as one lot. Multiple Tom Brady, Sammy Sosa, Eli Manning, Payton Manning, and man

Sold

Sports lot Baseball and Football Cards, Walter Payton, (1 of 6)

Sports lot Baseball and Football Cards, Walter Payton,Sports lot Baseball and Football Cards, Walter Payton, Andre Dawson (Rookie), Frank Thomas, Buttons, Graded Daunte Culpepper, Jerry Rice, Emmet Smith, Payton Manning, Troy Aikman, Signed Bob Feller wi

Sold

Signed Peyton Manning & Tom Brady Photo COA (1 of 4)

Signed Peyton Manning & Tom Brady Photo COA Signed Payton Manning and Tom Brady Photo COA. Berner's does not guarantee authenticity of signatures or COA. Framed Size Apx. 11 1/2" W x 9 1/2" H. Photos are considered part of the description and c

Sold

Peyton Manning Graded Card (1 of 4)

Peyton Manning Graded Card EMC Grading 2009 Topps #300, Payton Manning GEM MINT 10

Sold

McFarlane Football Figures Statues NIB - 3 Favre (1 of 1)

McFarlane Football Figures Statues NIB - 3 Favre Payton Manning

Sold

Football Helmet signed by Peyton Eli and Archie Manning (1 of 5)

Football Helmet signed by Peyton Eli and Archie Manning Football Helmet signed by Eli, Payton & Archie Manning w/Steiner sticker - 100% guaranteed authentic! Description: Gorgeous helmet with all (3) QB's! Talk about pedigree! Wowsa! Request more informati

Sold

Huge Football Card Binder, 100s of Cards (1 of 7)

Huge Football Card Binder, 100s of Cards Binder Filled with football cards from various years and sets. Includes Emmitt Smith, Troy Aikman, Walter Payton, Peyton Manning and more. All items are sold as is. Please look at pictures carefully t

Sold

2 AUTOGRAPHED PHOTOS P. MANNING & WALTER PAYTON W/COA'S (1 of 10)

2 AUTOGRAPHED PHOTOS P. MANNING & WALTER PAYTON W/COA'S LOT (2) AUTOGRAPHED PHOTOS PEYTON MANNING & WALTER PAYTON W/COA'S, 8" X 10", FRAMED

Sold

Walter Payton Signed Photo Plaque (1 of 2)

Walter Payton Signed Photo Plaque Walter Payton signed photo plaque. Plaques of Stacks COA on reverse. Measures 13" x 10"

Sold

Payton and Eli Manning Hallmark Keepsake Ornaments (1 of 1)

Payton and Eli Manning Hallmark Keepsake Ornaments Payton and Eli Manning Hallmark Keepsake Ornaments

TOP