LOT OF VINTAGE FISHING LURES AND FLIESHartzell's Auction Gallery, Inc.4.7(1.4k)$35(2 bids)2 days Left
Art Mendel, Bill Kiersteil and Others. 13 Ice Decoys and Lures.Slotin Folk Art4.8(628)$100(1 bid)Feb 07, 2026
Sold2 Pflueger Scoop MinnowsBoth with good glass eyes and marked front prop, includes a large size in meadow frog (Ex-) and a 3" mid-size in silver sparks/green back (Ex-/Ex), coming in its correctly marked "Size 3 No. 9303" boxSee Sold Price
SoldLot Of 2: Pflueger 3 Hook Neverfail Minnows.Pair of Pflueger 3 hook Neverfail minnows, marked front props.See Sold Price
SoldPFLUEGER 2 HOOK FLOATING MONARCH MINNOW2 - 3/4” Length. Nice example dating to 1913 with super clean hardware and glass eyes (right is hairlined). Finished in white with red nose, this bait has pointed tube props with the Bulldog onSee Sold Price
SoldPflueger All-In-One MinnowBright rainbow finish, good glass eyes and Neverfail hardware, rigged with a #1 lip (and including an interchangeable #2 lip), appearing unfished, shiny Ex- condition with light wear and tight age linSee Sold Price
SoldPflueger Surprize MinnowFinished in rarely seen "Natural Frog - Scale Finish", good glass eyes, stenciled mouth, Ex- with a few small nicks, wear, light soiling and age lines. The box grades about VG+, marked "3 1/2 No. 7610See Sold Price
SoldPflueger Surprise MinnowThree hook with Neverfail rigging, chub scale finish, hole eyes and SURPRISE stamped in the mouth, shiny Ex-. Coming in a blue border box marked 5407 Nat. Chub Scale 2 3/4" (Baby O'Boy Minnow) that grSee Sold Price
Sold(2) VINTAGE PFLUEGER FISHING LURESEarly version surprise minnow with holes for eyes and an O'boy frog scale minnow with glass eyes. 3" to 4" long.See Sold Price
SoldPflueger Surprise Minnow Box with All In One MinnowPflueger. American, circa 1910s. Original box. 2" x 5.75" x 1.5". GRADE: VG-, Box Wear. Est. $150 - 200See Sold Price
SoldPflueger Catalina MinnowEarly "flatside" minnow dating from the teens, 4 1/2", finished in black back with bright blue sides blended to aluminum with red hand painted gill marks. Featuring a bulldog marked rear bow tie spinnSee Sold Price
SoldLot Of 2: A&I and Pflueger.Pair of early baits, A&I Glowbody and a Pflueger Pearl Minnow.See Sold Price
SoldKingfisher Wood Minnow Box2-way slide top box is unmarked for color/model but retains the majority of its paper top label and comes with a bright green crackleback Pflueger Neverfail minnow. The lure features red hand paintedSee Sold Price
SoldPflueger Live Wire MinnowBaby model in perch scale, 3 1/2", rhinestone eyes, floppy props marked Live Wire and with the bulldog logo, Ex-/Ex, most likely unfished. In the tough correct box marked "Size 3 1/2 No. 7606 Nat-PercSee Sold Price
SoldPflueger Neverfail Wooden MinnowScarce Enterprise Manufacturing Company slide lid wood box is marked for the small size 2 3/4 minnow, No. 3185, with wear/rubs mostly to the top label and the wood a bit age darkened. Coming with a raSee Sold Price
SoldPflueger All-In-One, Green Crackleback Finish.Absolutely stunning condition on this Pflueger All-In-One Minnow finished in green crackleback with rhinestone eyes, neverfail hardware, and the fancy #2 surface lip. No upgrade necessary!See Sold Price
SoldEarly Pflueger Mustang Minnow PrototypeMost likely a test bait, factory scratched on the underside of the large scoop lip "6-25-40 Job 43132M.A", rigged with a single line tie screw and standard surface hardware as it was never rigged withSee Sold Price
SoldPair of Pflueger BaitsIncludes an Excellent 3 1/2" Shiner Scale Live Wire Minnow with red jeweled eyes and an Excellent early Green Scale Wizard Wiggler with just some very light wear.See Sold Price
Sold2 Pflueger LuresEach in a blue border box with good glass eyes and marked lip. O'Boy in bright blue mullet scale, Ex-/Ex, in a solid but worn box that's stamped 5403 Nat. Mullet Scale. And a 3 3/8" Palomine, about ExSee Sold Price
SoldDealer Box Pflueger MinnowsPflueger, United States. 1950s. Boxed. Ballerina Scramble, Palomine R/W, Neverfail Perch. Material: Wood. Quantity: 3. Grade: VG. 5" boxes. Est. $125-150.See Sold Price
Sold2 Pflueger Musky GlobesEach the large 5 1/4 size with bulldog marked wing, surface hardware and coming in the correct canoe box with insert. Includes red head pike scale (unfished Ex-/Ex) and yellow with gold spots (VG+/Ex-See Sold Price
Sold2 Pflueger Buckeye Casting ReelsEach a 60 yard size, the first coming in the correct tall maroon box, with jeweled caps, dual ivory handle grasps and good working click/drag switches, the second also with jeweled caps, good workingSee Sold Price
Sold2 Pflueger PalominesBoth in rainbow with a marked lip, surface hardware and good glass eyes, 4 3/8” standard size grades near Ex, the Baby is Ex-/Ex, coming in a VG box marked "3 1/4 No. 5078 Rainbow" with a paperSee Sold Price
Sold2 Pflueger PalominesBoth finished in frog scale with a marked lip and surface hardware, Baby grades shiny Ex, standard is about VG+/Ex-.See Sold Price
Sold2- PFLUEGER NOBBY FISHING REELSNice pair of vintage fishing reels. Both are complete and working. ExcellentSee Sold Price
Sold(2)Pflueger Medalist Fly Fishing Reels - #1494 1/2 DA + 333 DT7F Double(2)Pflueger Medalist Fly Fishing Reels - #1494 1/2 DA + 333 DT7F DoubleSee Sold Price
