5 GRADED CARDS BRADY/W. PAYTON/FAVRE/MARINO/P. MANNINGEstateOfMind Auctions4.5(308)$80(2 bids)Feb 21, 2026
Peyton Manning Rookie Card 1998 Fleer Brilliants #120 Indianapolis ColtsWestern Pennsylvania Trading Inc.4.7(167)$1(1 bid)Feb 17, 2026
Peyton Manning Strike Force Insert 1999 Upper Deck #SF-11 Indianapolis ColtsWestern Pennsylvania Trading Inc.4.7(167)$1(1 bid)Feb 07, 2026
Peyton Manning 2002 SP Authentic Autographs Colts PSA 9/10 Auto #91Activity Auctions4.5(382)$7003 days Left
Peyton Manning Hall of Fame Insert 2025 Panini Mosaic #296 Indianapolis ColtsWestern Pennsylvania Trading Inc.4.7(167)$1Feb 07, 2026
2002 Topps #316 Dwight Freeney Autographed PSA Slabbed Colts CardMynt Auctions4.4(820)$1004 days Left
John Elway 1997 Pinnacle Action Packed #10 Denver BroncosWestern Pennsylvania Trading Inc.4.7(167)$1Feb 10, 2026
Sold2000 TOPPS CHROME BLUE NO.16 PEYTON MANNING (GCG 9)2000 TOPPS CHROME BLUE NO.16 PEYTON MANNING (GCG 9)See Sold Price
Sold2000 TOPPS FINEST PEYTON MANNING MINT 92000 TOPPS FINEST PEYTON MANNING MINT 9 PAASSee Sold Price
Sold2007-08 FLEER ULTRA NO.FG-PM PEYTON MANNING FIELD GENERALS (GCG 9.5)2007-08 FLEER ULTRA NO.FG-PM PEYTON MANNING FIELD GENERALS (GCG 9.5)See Sold Price
SoldPeyton Manning 2002 Topps Chrome Own The Game #OG2 HofPeyton Manning 2002 Topps Chrome Own The Game #OG2 HofSee Sold Price
Sold2002 TOPPS NO.H3 SPIDEY HOLOGRAM (GCG 9.5)2002 TOPPS NO.H3 SPIDEY HOLOGRAM (GCG 9.5)See Sold Price
SoldPeyton Manning Topps Finest Refractor GMA 9Peyton Manning Topps Finest Refractor GMA 9See Sold Price
SoldPeyton Manning Topps Strata Graded CWTC 9.5Peyton Manning Topps Strata Graded CWTC 9.5See Sold Price
Sold1998 Topps Certified A10 Bronze Peyton Manning Signed Rookie Card (SGC 9)Autographed 1998 Topps Certified #A10 Bronze Peyton Manning NFL Football Trading Card (Rookie Card) (SGC 9). Peyton Manning undoubtedly needs to be in the conversation regarding the greatest quarterbaSee Sold Price
SoldPeyton Manning 1998 Topps #360 RC (PSA 9)Card has been graded (PSA) 9. Please see scans for details regarding the condition of the card (Indianapolis Coltss).See Sold Price
SoldGCG GRADED 9.5 PANINI FOOTBALL CARD LOT (TOM BRADY/ PEYTON MANNING)GCG GRADED 9.5 PANINI FOOTBALL CARD LOT (TOM BRADY/ PEYTON MANNING)See Sold Price
SoldPeyton Manning Rookie 1998 Topps Finest PSA 9 Football CardPeyton Manning Rookie 1998 Topps Finest Graded- PSA 9See Sold Price
SoldGroup of 9 Sports Figures and Bobble HeadsIncludes 2001 Play Makers Eddie George and Peyton Manning, 2002 Play Makers Brian Urlacher and Tiger Woods, 2000 NFC Peyton Manning stamper, 1999 Superstars Grant Hill and 2 Dennis Rodman, and 1997 StSee Sold Price
Sold40+ 1963 - 2012 Football Cards with HOFs, Graded Cards1995 SP Terrell Davis BGS 9 Rookie, 1963 Topps Boyd Dowler PSA 6, 2012 HA Peerless Harry Carson Auto 21/25, 2005 Topps Finest Refractor Peyton Manning 71/599, 1999 Skybox Ex Century Peyton Manning InsSee Sold Price
SoldThree Graded Football/rookies Stars1981 Topps Joe Montana Bvg 5.5, 1990 Topps Traded Emmitt Smith Rookie Sgc 60 Ex 5, 1998 Bowman Peyton Manning Rookie Sgc 9See Sold Price
Sold(9) 1980's & 90's Topps Football Cards(9) Topps Football cards. 1998 Peyton Manning draft pick, 360. 1986 Jerry Rice #80, 49ers, card 161. (2) 1985 Warren Moon, Oilers, card 251. 1998 Randy Moss, draft picks, card 352. 1982 Joe Montana inSee Sold Price
SoldPeyton Manning Refractor 2006 Topps Chrome #8 PSA 9Peyton Manning Refractor 2006 Topps Chrome #8 PSA 9See Sold Price