5 GRADED CARDS BRADY/W. PAYTON/FAVRE/MARINO/P. MANNINGEstateOfMind Auctions4.5(308)$80(2 bids)Feb 21, 2026
Peyton Manning Rookie Card 1998 Fleer Brilliants #120 Indianapolis ColtsWestern Pennsylvania Trading Inc.4.7(167)$1(1 bid)Feb 17, 2026
Peyton Manning Strike Force Insert 1999 Upper Deck #SF-11 Indianapolis ColtsWestern Pennsylvania Trading Inc.4.7(167)$1(1 bid)Feb 07, 2026
Peyton Manning 2002 SP Authentic Autographs Colts PSA 9/10 Auto #91Activity Auctions4.5(382)$7003 days Left
2002 Topps #316 Dwight Freeney Autographed PSA Slabbed Colts CardMynt Auctions4.4(820)$1004 days Left
Peyton Manning Hall of Fame Insert 2025 Panini Mosaic #296 Indianapolis ColtsWestern Pennsylvania Trading Inc.4.7(167)$1Feb 07, 2026
Peyton Manning HOF Autographed 7x7 Colts Photo Upper Deck CertifiedMynt Auctions4.4(820)$1002 days Left
Sold2005 Upper Deck Peyton Manning Debut #41 IGX 102005 Upper Deck Peyton Manning Debut #41 IGX 10See Sold Price
Sold2005 UPPER DECK #41 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE DEBUT (10 GEM2005 UPPER DECK #41 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE DEBUT (10 GEM MINT)See Sold Price
Sold2005 UPPER DECK NO.41 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE DEBUT (GEM MINT 10)2005 UPPER DECK NO.41 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE DEBUT (GEM MINT 10)See Sold Price
SoldPeyton Manning Rookie Debut 2005 Upper Deck #41 Colts Football CardUpper Deck, Vintage Football NFL Trading Cards, Old Sports Cards for Sale Near Me, Hall of Fame & Super Bowl Player Cards, Auction Memorabilia Lots for Sale on LineSee Sold Price
SoldGem 10 Upper Deck PEYTON MANNING Rookie Football CardGem Mint 10 1999 Upper Deck Choice Rookie Class Rookie Football Card / Multiple Photos PostedSee Sold Price
SoldPeyton Manning 2005 Upper Deck Sp Authentic Base #36 ColtsPeyton Manning 2005 Upper Deck Sp Authentic Base #36 ColtsSee Sold Price
Sold1998 UPPER DECK NO.193 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE CARD FGS GRADED 10Prices are in Canadian dollarsSee Sold Price
Sold1999 Upper Deck UD Peyton Manning Quarterback Class1999 Upper Deck UD Peyton Manning Quarterback Class QC13 SGC 10 Colts HOFSee Sold Price
SoldPeyton Manning 2006 Upper Deck Rookie Debut Football #42 ColtsPeyton Manning 2006 Upper Deck Rookie Debut Football #42 ColtsSee Sold Price
SoldAllen Iverson 2005 Upper Deck Rookie Debut #69Allen Iverson 2005 Upper Deck Rookie Debut #69 Philadelphia 76'ErsSee Sold Price
SoldFrank Gore Game Used RC Patch 2005 Upper Deck Rookie Debut #SA-FRFrank Gore Game Used RC Patch 2005 Upper Deck Rookie Debut #SA-FRSee Sold Price
Sold1999 Upper Deck Ovation Peyton Manning #231999 Upper Deck Ovation Peyton Manning #23See Sold Price
Sold1999 UPPER DECK BLACK DIAMOND PEYTON MANNING GRADED ISA MINT 91999 UPPER DECK BLACK DIAMOND PEYTON MANNING GRADED ISA MINT 9See Sold Price
Sold2005 Upper Deck NFL Rookie Debut, Aaron Rodgers #126, (R)2005 Upper Deck NFL Rookie Debut, Aaron Rodgers, Card #126; RookieSee Sold Price
Sold2000 Upper Deck Black Diamond Peyton Manning #462000 Upper Deck Black Diamond Peyton Manning #46See Sold Price
Sold1999 Upper Deck Strike Force Peyton Manning #SF111999 Upper Deck Strike Force Peyton Manning #SF11 Indianapolis ColtsSee Sold Price
Sold98 UD CHOICE PEYTON MANNING RCTitle: 98 UD CHOICE PEYTON MANNING RC Description: VERY NICE 1998 UPPER DECK UD CHOICE PEYTON MANNING ROOK QUEST W/ JOHN ELWAY STAR QUEST HOLFOIL THIS IS A VERY NICE CARD FOR ANY COLLECTOR. THIS CARDSee Sold Price
Sold2005 Upper Deck Signature Portraits Archie Manning and Joe Thiesmann2005 Upper Deck Signature Portraits Archie Manning and Joe ThiesmannSee Sold Price
Sold1999 UPPER DECK BLACK DIAMOND #D14 PEYTON MANNING POP 41999 UPPER DECK BLACK DIAMOND #D14 PEYTON MANNING POP 4 PSA 9See Sold Price
Sold1999 Upper Deck NFL Trading Cards, Peyton Manning Retro #63Upper Deck, Vintage Football NFL Trading Cards, Old Sports Cards for Sale Near Me, Hall of Fame & Super Bowl Player Cards, Auction Memorabilia Lots for Sale on LineSee Sold Price
Sold2004 Peyton Manning Upper Deck Diamond Collection #672004 Peyton Manning Upper Deck Diamond Collection #67 ColtsSee Sold Price
Sold2005-06 UPPER DECK PHENOMENAL BEGINNINGS #10 SIDNEY2005-06 UPPER DECK PHENOMENAL BEGINNINGS #10 SIDNEY CROSBY GAME USED JERSEY (10 MINT)See Sold Price
Sold1998 UD CHOICE PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE CARDTitle: 1998 UD CHOICE PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE CARD Date/Period: MODERN Additional Information: 1998 UPPER DECK CHOICE - ROOKIE QUEST PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE CARD W/ JOHN ELWAY STAR QUEST. HELLO! THANK YOUSee Sold Price
SoldPEYTON MANNING SIGNED UPPER DECKVINTAGE SIGNATURES CARD PMVS by UPPER DECK - NO COASee Sold Price
