Leighton Galleries, NJ - Read over 188 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Leighton Galleries (188)

badge TOP RATED
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 188 Reviews

Regina
Wayne, NJ

Dec 26, 2025
Wonderful
Great experience. Professional and kind.
Report
(7) PC JUDITH RIPKA STERLING JEWELRY GROUP +1

American Pawn Company
North Fort Myers, FL

Nov 08, 2025
As described
Will buy from again
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesNov 09, 2025
Bruce, thank you. We are looking forward to it.
14K AMETHYST CABOCHON FANCY RING SIGNED VAN GOGH

Benjamin
Kyneton, AU

Oct 10, 2025
A + + +
Amazing experience and amazing watches, thank you so much.
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesNov 09, 2025
Thank you, Benjamin, for the kind words. We appreciate you.
GENTS VINTAGE LONGINES 14K GOLD CASE WATCH

Virginia
Lake Forest, IL

Jun 30, 2025
Five star treatment!
So kind and helpful First time bidding out of state Hoped for the best Got the best Thank you do much
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesJun 30, 2025
Thank you, Virginia. I'm happy you found that family piece you sought. Blessings, and have a wonderful summer.
MARIE KOUPAL LUSK (Illinois, 1862-1929)

James Mussallem Treasures LLC
Jacksonville, FL

Mar 13, 2025
FRITZ WAGNER (German, 1896-1939)

Tom
Wayne, MI

Dec 26, 2024
First class operation!
I was thoroughly impressed with every aspect of my last auction purchase from Leighton Galleries. Very responsive and professional staff, quick processing of my order, all the necessary documentation handled by email, easy payment process. Shipping cost seemed high to me, UNTIL I actually received my package. My item was a large framed photograph with fragile glass and delicate frame details. I was extremely impressed with the degree of protection given to my item — multiple layers & double boxed — which was appropriate for such an irreplaceable object. The cost was justified, and I am very pleased overall. Highly recommend these folks!
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesDec 26, 2024
Tom, thank you very, very much. What you experienced is what we shoot for, and almost always accomplish, with each and every buyer experience. Our UPS store has had this business for over 10 + years and has always done an exceptional job. I will pass it along to them. Thank you again. John
FULL PLATE TINTED TINTYPE - AFRICAN AMERICAN GENT

Mark
Meriden, CT

Dec 13, 2024
Bid with confidence.
Fantastic experience. Streamlined payment and shipping, very fast responses via email. Highly recommended. Would bid again with zero hesitation. Thank you!
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesDec 15, 2024
Mark, thank you. I hope you enjoy your purchase as much as you enjoyed your buying experience. We look forward to working with you in the future. Merry Christmas. John
(30) CHILD IMAGES IN MOSTLY DOUBLE UNION CASES

Joseph
Candor, NC

Oct 19, 2024
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesOct 20, 2024
Hope you enjoy the music boxes. Thank you Joseph
LARGE F CONCHON SWISS CYLINDER MUSIC BOX

David
Lewes, DE

Sep 26, 2024
Great buying experience!
I wouldn't hesitate to purchase from this auctioneer. Very professional and great communication. They work with UPS to have your items shipped, overall fantastic experience. 5 Stars from me!
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesSep 27, 2024
Thank you, David. Enjoy the Wemyss piggies!!
MEDIUM WEMYSS FOR PLICHTA THISTLE MONEYBANK PIG

Ruth
Canyon Lake, TX

Sep 26, 2024
Everything worked like clockwork!
Very happy with the entire experience.
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesSep 26, 2024
Thank you, Ruth.
CARL J. SMITH (Texas, b.1928)

Tatyana
San Francisco, CA

Sep 28, 2023
Excellent Auction House
Easy and smooth transaction start to finish, highly recommend this auction house.
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesSep 29, 2023
Thank you, and we appreciate YOU.
14K DOUBLE STRAND PEARL CHOKER

Katharine
Asheville, NC

Sep 28, 2023
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesSep 29, 2023
Katherine, thank you
14K WIDE SLIDE HINGED BANGLE

Isaac
Great Neck, NY

Jun 23, 2023
professionalism
i’m a dealer for more than 20 years i deal with many auction houses. it’s my experience that Leighton auction is the most reliable, trustworthy, professional and honest auction around
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesJun 23, 2023
Thank you Isaac. Your comments are very much appreciated. You are a wonderful customer who exhibits the very same traits you attribute to us. We value your business, and most importantly, you. Thank you
14K OMEGA CHOKER WITH DIAMOND INFINITY PENDANT

Min
Elkhart, IN

Jun 22, 2023
Honest and respectable
Honest and respectable auctioner.
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesJun 23, 2023
Thank you Min. It is appreciated.
(15) PIECE JEWELRY GROUP, MOST 14K

FRANK
Atlantic City, NJ

Jun 22, 2023
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesJun 22, 2023
Thank you Frank.
(13) ONE OUNCE SILVER BULLION COIN ROUNDS

Walter
Palm Desert, CA

Jun 22, 2023
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesJun 22, 2023
Thank you Walter. Enjoy the watch. It's lovely.
LADIES CARTIER STAINLESS TANK SOLO WATCH REF 3170

Joe
Fort Lauderdale, FL

Mar 17, 2023
Great Auctioneer!
Nice transaction all the way through. Good and honest auctioneer. Highly recommended. Thank you
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesMay 23, 2023
Thank you, it is appreciated.
18K TIFFANY & CO. FLOWER PIN

John
Key West, FL

Dec 25, 2022
Easy Easy, See it, buy it, sit back.
Total pros folks, buy with confidence, its headache free. Seamless shipping.
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesFeb 11, 2023
Thank you John.
KIT KARBLER & MICHAEL DAVID (Colorado, 20/21st C.)

Frank
Fallbrook, CA

Nov 17, 2022
Fantastic all around
Just wonderful all the way
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesNov 17, 2022
Thank you, Frank. We really appreciate it.
(5) ORNATELY FRAMED PORTRAIT MINIATURES

Paul
San Antonio, TX

Oct 01, 2022
Great Experiance!
First time to buy from this auction house. Sent them my absentee bids, got a great price, and they got the items to me without any problems. I would recommend them and will for sure look at their next auction!
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesOct 02, 2022
Thank you, Paul. It was great to do business with you as well.
(63) PIECE WALLACE STERLING FLATWARE SERVICE

Otar
White Plains, NY

Sep 29, 2022
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesOct 02, 2022
Otar, thank you for your continued business. We appreciate you.
(65) PIECE HEIRLOOM STERLING FLATWARE SERVICE

David
Winter Garden, FL

Jul 01, 2022
What you see is what you get!
What you see is what you get! My item was exactly what was pictured and described in their catalog. I am certainly satisfied...... 5 *****.
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesFeb 11, 2023
Thank you
TIFFANY STUDIOS BRONZE LAMP BASE #28609

mr
Norwood, NJ

Jun 20, 2022
best around
best in new jersey auction
Report
(11) US SILVER EAGLE $1 COINS - ALL PCGS MS70

Philip
Swedesboro, NJ

Nov 15, 2021
1982 SOUTH AFRICAN KRUGERRAND GOLD COIN

Marie
Summit, NJ

Nov 11, 2021
Very easy to work with.
Easy to work with and friendly customer service.
Report
VINTAGE SALMON CORAL BEAD NECKLACE WITH 14K CLASP

James Mussallem Treasures LLC
Jacksonville, FL

Oct 29, 2021
ANTONIO RIVAS (Italy/Spain, 1845-1911)

Nuna
Gloucester, MA

Oct 25, 2021
Amazing Painting-As described and more
Thank you so much for making this painting available. I am thrilled with this transaction in every way. A + + + + +
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesOct 25, 2021
Thank you, Nuna for your kind words. We try hard and comments like yours are truly appreciated. John
ARNOLD BLANCH (Woodstock, NY 1896-1968)

Limei
Raleigh, NC

Aug 26, 2021
BLUE BAROQUE PEARL NECKLACE & EARRINGS

Zach
Raleigh, NC

Aug 19, 2021
Inaccurate description
I won a sterling silver flatware service whose description said "no monograms". When I received it three of the largest pieces clearly have a monogram. I would not have bid as much for this set if I had known it was monogramed.
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesAug 19, 2021
Zach, a review of the images confirms the absolute accuracy of your comment. We apologize. I assure you it was unintentional. We will endeavor to assure the full accuracy and transparency of our descriptions. Contact me directly and we will work out a credit to your full satisfaction. John **********
(37) PIECE GORHAM STERLING FLATWARE SERVICE

Rich
Boise, ID

Jul 06, 2021
great transaction
excellent description of lot, great auction
Report
ANGELO BASSO (Italian, 1943-2011)

Satinder
Jersey City, NJ

Jun 27, 2021
18K YELLOW SAPPHIRE & DIAMOND DOME RING

Ryan
Romney, IN

Apr 30, 2021
WOODROW WILSON SIGNED LETTER

Satinder
Jersey City, NJ

Apr 29, 2021
14K TURQUOISE & SEED PEARL LOCKET BROOCH

Steven
Blairstown, NJ

Apr 29, 2021
TIFFANY & CO.HEMATITE BEADED NECKLACE

chris
Redmond, WA

Apr 29, 2021
Nicely done!
I had a great experience with the auction and the items. All described well and quality items. The shipping was very expensive through a 3rd party, but they did package very well and everything arrived safe. Thank you!
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesApr 29, 2021
Thanks Chris. You had some fairly large framed items, and big boxes can get pricy to ship by UPS. Glad they arrived safely. John
1959 MEXICAN VEINTE PESOS GOLD COIN

Kevin
Fort Myers, FL

Mar 07, 2021
MAITLAND SMITH BRONZE FIGURAL MONKEY LAMP

RONALD
Stockbridge, GA

Feb 27, 2021
LADIES OMEGA 14K DIAMOND BRACELET WATCH

Glen
York, PA

Feb 25, 2021
Professionally Run Organization
I've done business with Leighton Galleries on 3 occasions. Their customer service exceeded my expectations on every occasion.
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesMay 23, 2023
Glen, thank you. We appreciate YOU.
100+ US SILVER QUARTER COINS

Robert
San Diego, CA

Feb 25, 2021
19THC. EX-VOTO STYLE DEVOTIONAL PAINTING

Rand
Franklin Lakes, NJ

Feb 25, 2021
Outstanding service
It was a pleasure to deal with the staff at Leighton. Scheduling pickup and receiving my item was easy, and everyone was friendly and helpful.
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesMay 23, 2023
You and Connie are great people. Thank you for the kind comments.
DANIEL F. WENTWORTH (American, 1850-1934)

Dave
Midland Park, NJ

Feb 25, 2021
1886-S $5 HALF EAGLE US GOLD COIN

Anna
Vincentia, AU

Dec 25, 2020
(3) PAIRS 14K EARRINGS

Michael
Southaven, MS

Dec 24, 2020
Shipping
Buyers have to arrange pick up, packing and shipping.
Report
Leighton Galleries logo
Leighton GalleriesDec 26, 2020
No, Michael. No one has to do that. Just to clarify, once payment is made to Leighton, we forward a release to a local UPS store. They automatically pick up your items and initiate contact with you regarding shipping options, rates, insurance, etc. You only need to reply to their email. You do not have to arrange either pick-up, packing, or shipping. Perhaps you have confused our proven system with another auction firm? But, thank you for the 4 stars.
GENTS GRUEN VERI-THIN 14K GOLD CASE WATCH

Maurice
Plattsburgh, NY

Dec 24, 2020
Professional
Very professional operation with prompt contact upon sale to assistance with safe and secured quick shipping
Report
(5) GOLD ART GLASS LAMP SHADES

Anne
Englewood, NJ

Dec 24, 2020
10K DIAMOND TENNIS BRACELET

Art by Lilia,
Feasterville Trevose, PA

Dec 06, 2020
Wonderful experience
Many thanks to this auction for the accurate description and assistance! Super!
Report
PAIR MURANO GLASS WINGED DRAGON-FORM CANDLESTICKS

Linda
Bonner, AU

Oct 30, 2020
The Best!!!
What a wonderful experience. From bidding through to shipping, just the best. Thank you!
Report
CHANEL RED QUILTED LAMBSKIN CAMERA BAG

Paul
Sonoma, CA

Oct 30, 2020
Excellent auction house to deal with!!
Smooth transaction; very helpful staff. I hope to do business with them again
Report
LARGE RETRO CITRINE, RUBY & DIAMOND CLIP BROOCH

chris
Redmond, WA

Oct 29, 2020
DIVERSE US VINTAGE SILVER & NON SILVER COIN GROUP

Tamara
Urbana, IL

Oct 29, 2020
(2) PAIRS 14K EARRINGS