Bidder Reviews for Bodnar's Auction Sales (675)

Excellent transaction. Great price on a quality item. Shipping was really fast and the product was well packaged and arrived in excellent condition. Very affordable shipping. When I received the product it was exactly as described and pictured. Excellent service, great product Excellent service, great product and fast shipping. Can't ask for better than that. I'll be saving this A1 + Sellers

Overall it was a very good experience.

I do not quite remember having bid for the item (although I definitely looked at it), and having received it, this item is definitely not to my liking. This said, the auction house execution was perfect-from follow up to payment to shipment. MOST IMPORTANTLY is that unlike LiveAuctioneers who provide a possibility to ship at a pre-determined cost (which somehow always ends up being TOO EXPENSIVE), this auction house makes its money on the auction, and once a product is sold provides logistics as a service. AND WHAT A SERVICE IT IS! LiveAuctioneers-you can definitely look and learn!

Proper packaging, frame is beautiful and price was phenomenal

Will be keeping an eye for more items in the future.

Left review on Google.

Item as described, will purchase from again

Faberge egg is fantastic, it's a peace of art, gorgeous!

Challenges with shipping and pickup widow. I was told that I should have read the fine print before auction. Look at past feedback left on the seller left by other buyers, my complaint is the same. I am local to Seller (NJ both), thought it would have been easier. Actual items won were fine, as described in the auction, no issues with that.

I always look at what Bodnar's has to offer as they list amazing items!!

Great Company

I purchased my son’s Christmas gift and it arrived on time and very very well packaged and protected from damage 👍 🏼 👍 🏼 items exactly as pictured but better in person ❤ ️

The print has severe toning damage from cardboard backing. I wish they had examined the print out of the frame and included pictures that indicated that damage.

I purchased a side table for $40 and paid for it promptly. The shipping they recommended was over $500 to bring a tiny little table to Chicago. I arranged for my own shipping. My driver was unable to get to their private home before 4:00 on the appointed day and was not given access. He then continued with his route and was able to pick up the item 8 days later. Bodnar's then demanded that I pay an additional $80 in storage fees. If not, they would not allow the pick up. I cancelled the order and am currently waiting for a full refund. These people are nothing more than common thieves. Do yourself a favor and stay away.

Amazing auction house to purchase from!

Seamless win and shipping for reasonable price.

Bodnar's is a wonderful auction house to bid with!!

Great auction house that offers accurate, detailed pictures and descriptions, not to mention that the items I purchased arrived surprisingly just a few days after the auction. They clearly don't mess around! Thanks for such great service.

Extremely happy with auction house and third party shipper they recommended

Bodnar's handled this transaction perfectly from start to finish. I have received my item and it was packed beautifully. Thank. you!

Everything done with efficiency, items arrived swiftly. Very happy.

Shipping was exorbitant

item arrived quickly and appeared as described

Thanks so much for such a wonderful auction!!

Happy with item and service.

Beautifully packed for the journey...

The overall purchase, shipping, etc, was very good, the only issue was in not making sure I read the description properly. What the pictures show is a beautiful pearl necklace, what I received was closer to a necklace for a young child. I missed the part where it was only 14” and how big 3 mm pearls would be. So, the whole process overall was good, but I am disappointed in myself for not doing my due diligence first.

If you do not have a good monitor know that they do not mention missing stones in their written description.

I’ve had multiple bad experiences with auctions run by Joseph Bodnar, and I’m officially done. After winning several lots, he sent everything to a random UPS store that charged an outrageous fee for shipping. Even worse, the packaging was appalling — no bubble wrap, no padding, nothing. They literally tossed everything I won into a single large box and shipped it cross-country from New Jersey to California. Several items arrived damaged or broken due to their complete disregard for proper packing. When I contacted Bodnar directly, I was shocked by how rude and dismissive he was. From the very beginning, he treated my questions as an annoyance. His tone was condescending and hostile, as if I should be grateful just to be doing business with him. After a handful of emails — where he essentially shouted me down — he simply stopped responding altogether. Even when the UPS store seemingly lost my package for over a week, Bodnar offered no help, no guidance, and no accountability. This wasn’t a one-time issue. I’ve given him more than one chance, and each time I’ve regretted it. If you value your time, your money, or the condition of the items you win, I strongly urge you to avoid Joseph Bodnar auctions. There are many reputable auctioneers out there — this simply isn’t one of them.