George Cole Auctions, NY - Read over 414 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for George Cole Auctions (414)

badge TOP RATED
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 414 Reviews

Andra
New York, NY

Jan 31, 2026
DCS By Fisher & Paykel Stainless Steel Grill w/ Smoker, Steamer, Rotisserie 50" H X 40 1/2" W,

James
Port Orange, FL

Dec 31, 2025
Seamless
Fast turn around. great piece.
Report
Roseville Donatello Planter 6 3/4" H X 16 1/4" W X 7 1/4" D

Leonid
Brooklyn, NY

Dec 27, 2025
Great Staff
Great Staff
Report
Pr. Hand Carved Indonesian Face Masks 23" H X 5" W

Robert
West End, NC

Dec 27, 2025
Good Auctioneers
Bought a couple pieces from George Cole over past few years. No probs at all. Good people.
Report
Framed Watercolor Landscape Sgnd D.F. Hasbrouck 1915  19 1/2" X 13 1/2" w/Frame 27" X 21"

Marcy
Sharon, VT

Dec 27, 2025
Excellent Auction Experience
The bidding and payment process on LiveAuctioneers was seamless, and the item was well described. Crew onsite was VERY helpful and made the pick-up easy and convenient-many thanks!
Report
Howard Miller Greene Mission Style Oak Grandfather Clock 6'8" H X 24" W X 13" D

RJ
Brooklyn, NY

Dec 27, 2025
Victorian What Not Cabinet 71" H X 35 1/2" W X 15" D

W
Albany, NY

Dec 21, 2025
Gabbeh 9'10" Sq.

Marty
New Paltz, NY

Dec 01, 2025
Great Sale, Friendly Folks
Had a blast at this on line auction. Got great deals. Staff very friendly and helpful at pick up.
Report
Folk Art Carved Wooden Rooster w/Metal Wings & Tail J. Forbes 21" H X 18 1/2" L X 8" W

Mobile Exchange Gt Inc
Doral, FL

Nov 26, 2025
Lot Costume Jewelry

Stan
Jamaica Estates, NY

Sep 13, 2025
Staff was very helpful, patient and careful loading item into my jeep.
I appreciated the attention and assistance provided to me in ensuring that the item was well protected as the staff tried patiently to fit the table in my jeep. Thanks again for the persistence and skill in fitting the table and pedestals in the jeep.
Report
Double Pedestal Mahog & Burl Walnut Dining Table 30 1/2" H x 76 1/2" L X 44" D

Mark
Berlin, NY

Sep 13, 2025
I have a successful with the auction house for over 40 years.
If you are looking for a variety of items in the Hudson Valley, be sure to stop in at a George Cole Auction. You'll never be disappointed.
Report
Marble Pedestal 43 1/2" H X 12" Diam.

Roberto
Elizabeth City, NC

Sep 13, 2025
Silk Embroidered Shawl 6'4" Sq. -(Not Including Fringe)

Bruce
Ringgold, GA

Sep 13, 2025
They were very helpful through the process
I appreciate the professional response to my questions. I am very happy with the item won.
Report
African Rosewood Crucifix Figure 16" H X 17" W

Evert-Jan
Wildervank, NL

Aug 05, 2025
Framed O/Panel Dutch Street Scene Sgnd Gerardus Vertin 14" X 11" w/Frame 17" X 14 1/2"

PAUL
Reno, NV

Jul 30, 2025
Desk purchase
Arrived fine with little unexpected damage or wear. Am reasonably satisfied.
Report
C1890  Carved Walnut Desk 33 1/2" H X 61" W X 37 1/2" D

Kellie
Goshen, NY

Jun 15, 2025
BUYER BEWARE
The site does say BUYER BEWARE and it is absolutely true. My lamp had a broken panel. When asked if it was broken I was told it was a crease in the slide glass. After driving an hour and a half to pick up the lamp it was indeed broken. Extremely disappointed. 1st time leaving a bad review on Liveauctioneers!!
Report
George Cole Auctions logo
George Cole AuctionsJul 15, 2025
In Your message to us, You stated yourself: ... I'm very disappointed. I'm looking back at the pictures, and it looks to me like one of the panels may be broken?..." So it is clear that you discovered something purely by looking again at what we had posted the whole time. There were no tricks, there was no deception. You discovered something that was always there, & now you'd like to blame someone else for your dissatisfaction. That's fine, it is part of the auction business. What is not fair is to give a low rating making it seem as though we are doing dirty, when actually we did nothing wrong. Further, I was the person who brought your item out to you, when you came for pick up, you did not ask for an adjustment or even say anything at all about dissatisfaction. You wish someone would have posted some critque identifying every flaw. We have found that its impossible to predict, identify & list every flaw that may or may not be offensive to buyers all of whom have different tolerances & standards. So we take fair pictures, & let you the buyer be the judge. We answer all questions fairly & honestly and we're happy to provide extra pics when possible. For you & anyone else who cares to know, we post the following on every single lot: "BUYER BEWARE!!! We do our best in good faith to evaluate auction items, And we DO NOT try to hide flaws. But Remember, it is the Buyer's responsibility to inspect each lot and form their own opinions on condition, description, provenance, and validity BEFORE purchasing. The absence of a condition report does not imply that the lot is free from damage and wear. Please review all pictures posted on this listing and remember the pictures are intended to give general representation and are not necessarily the product of an intense effort focused on uncovering and exposing flaws. We encourage buyers to request a condition report and/or additional photos, and to research shipping costs PRIOR to bidding on any lot."
C 1915 Slag Glass Table Lamp 19" H X 14" Diam.

Steven
Staatsburg, NY

May 24, 2025
14K + Labradorite Pendant

Marlene
Longwood, FL

May 24, 2025
Hummel Group 170/III

Rachel
Cambridge, MA

Apr 08, 2025
Lot 22 Matted Paintings, Acrylics + Prints By Marilyn Kalish

Gil
Lakeville, CT

Mar 29, 2025
Empire Mahog 2 Drawer Drop Leaf Stand 29" H X 18" W X 17" D

Theresa
Chantilly, VA

Mar 29, 2025
Professionalism Quality Experienced and Integrity
Outstanding Experience-George Cole Auctions. Seamless transaction from beginning to receipt of item. Superb shipping options that went above and beyond to save money, and deliver safely. Auction house accurately described item and answered all my questions, and genuinely concerned about customer satisfaction. Highly recommended.
Report
19th C 3 Pc. Cast Bronze Candleabra - Center 24 1/2" H X 19" W, Pr. Side 16 1/2" H X 15 1/2" W

Elizabeth
Dania Beach, FL

Mar 26, 2025
A lovely grouping of wonderful items... thanks so much!!!
Bid with total confidence... everything was perfect!!!
Report
Tray 17 Royal Copenhagen Animal Figurines 2999, 2998, 758, 834, 1192, 373, 3140, 1441, 1045, 2266,

Kathleen
Duanesburg, NY

Mar 01, 2025
Pr. Brass + Marble Candleabra 13 1/2" H X 12" Diam.

CenTex
Hico, TX

Jan 26, 2025
Winchester Model 94 30 X 30

Pamela
Richfield, OH

Jan 24, 2025
Very Angry Man Working Here
Terrible experience. Have never spoken to a more rude individual responsible for assisting a buyer. I emailed the company advising who would be picking up my items, received a confirmation back, and then a few days later received a phone call telling me I needed to make arrangements for pick-up. I returned the call and started to explain the aforementioned when the angry man said, "NAME?" I was in the middle of telling him that the account had 2 names on it and he interrupted me and said, "You don't know your name?" I then told him if he would let me finish I would explain. I was then berated by the angry man and told, "Well then what are you calling for?" When I was returning THEIR call. Trust the reviews. Look at how he responds to them. This is who you are dealing with. Hope things get better for him. Worst auction house I've ever dealt with. Learn how to speak to people.
Report
Pr Gilt Framed Bevelled Mirrors 48"H X 24"W

Deborah
Boston, MA

Dec 31, 2024
Fabulous table with interesting trim
Love the new table! Was drawn to the size (perfect between two chairs) and the pretty circular trim. Looks great in living room with a glass top. Thank you to the team at George Cole for always being helpful and friendly.
Report
Oak 2 Tier Table 25 1/2"H X 22"W X 16"D

Deborah
Boston, MA

Dec 31, 2024
George Cole Auctions is the best
Always thrilled with items on offer, bidding experience and my new treasures. Happy with all my items from George Cole Auctions over the past 4 years and thrilled with the rug, tables and birdcage I won in the recent auction. Team is always friendly and helpful when I have questions about dimensions or other details in advance of auction. Last, I often drive from Boston to collect my items and have always found team friendly and helpful. Happy New Year!
Report
Hamadan 5' X 6'11"

W
Albany, NY

Dec 31, 2024
Herman Miller Eames Chair

Pam
Ulster Park, NY

Dec 29, 2024
My won item was sold to someone else
I arranged to come pick up my item (I had already paid). Drove 40 minutes to be told that someone else had already bought and picked up my item. They explained it happens sometimes as they are on different online auction sites. No phone call, no apology, just a shrug of the shoulders when I expressed my disappointment. Never bidding there again.
Report
Tray 36 pc. Vintage Metal Photo Badges w/ Mirror Backs 2" diam + 2 3/4" X 1 3/4" + 2 -6" diam No

Olga
New Milford, CT

Dec 28, 2024
Capo Di Monte Porcelian and Brass Mantel Clock 22"H X 14 1/2"W X 7 1/2"D

NICOLE
Brooklyn, NY

Nov 24, 2024
Persian 6'4" X 9'4"

Adam
Germantown, NY

Nov 23, 2024
Lot 3 Sisal Carpets 4' X 6'

Penelope
Catskill, NY

Nov 23, 2024
Pr Octogonal Cast Cement Planters 11 1/2"H X 17"Diam

Daniel
Mamaroneck, NY

Nov 11, 2024
The Auction House staff was very helpful in answering my questions and concerns.
I have found several items that I placed bids on and won several, The staff was great answering my questions and very helpful arranging pickup of my items.
Report
Tray 4 Thai Wooden Wall Hangings 9"H X 7"W, 8 3/4"H X 5"W, 7 1/4"H X 6 1/4"W, 8"H X 5"W

Kevin
Camden, SC

Oct 28, 2024
19th C Walnut Base Marble Top Console Table 33 1/2"H X 47"W X 24"D

Don
Poughquag, NY

Oct 26, 2024
40's Walnut Base Marble Top Coffee Table 14 1/4" X 39"W X 23"D

Don
Poughquag, NY

Sep 03, 2024
Well organized professional auction house...
Easy to locate and good access. Helpful staff...
Report
Pair Chinese Blue & White Vase Lamps 23"

James
Monroe, CT

Aug 17, 2024
19th C Pine 2 Shelf Crock Stand 36"H X 37"W X 11 1/2"D

CATHY
Chandler, TX

Jul 20, 2024
Cross Stitch Quilt 6'7" X 7'9"

Jason
Moorestown, NJ

Jul 20, 2024
Thanks!
Easy, professional transaction, highly recommended.
Report
Aimoni Mfg Co NY C1915 Oak Stool 13 1/2"H X 16 1/4"W X 10 1/2"D

Ramon
Jamaica Plain, MA

Jul 10, 2024
Overall, a great experience.
Item was exactly as described. Transaction went smoothly. Shipping was quick.
Report
Buffet Clariner R13 #118778

Robert
Hudson, NY

Jun 24, 2024
Great Local Auction in the Hudson Valley
Always find something interesting here!
Report
Tray Lead Soldiers

Robert
Dover Plains, NY

Jun 22, 2024
Framed Triptych Religious Print 28" X 55 1/2"

Larry
Amenia, NY

Jun 22, 2024
No
Good
Report
Prim Pine 2 Drawer Harvest Table 47 1/2"W X 7'5"L

Anatoly
Brooklyn, NY

Jun 22, 2024
Very Happy with this Auction House Thank you.
Very Happy with this Auction House Thank you.
Report
14K Pave Diam Ring

Patricia
Waterville, WA

Jun 03, 2024
Outsider Art O/B "24 hrs a day" Sgnd Tannin 32" X 26"(woodstock artist)

John
Hebron, CT

May 26, 2024
C 1840 Shaler 1 Drawer Wk Table-  Watervalit Or Mt Lebanon

Felice
New York, NY

May 25, 2024
Pr Mahog Frame Armchairs 37"H X 31"W X 19"D

Nicholas
Troy, PA

May 20, 2024
19th C Tin Muff + Collar Bx W/ Mink Muff + Collars 9"H X 10 1/2"W X 7 1/2"D

William
Waverly, OH

Apr 30, 2024
Blue Dec 4 Gal Stoneware Jug