Rick Bonenberger Estate Auction #1 - Day 2 2026-02-06 Auction - 379 Price Results - Matthews Auctions, LLC in WI
LiveAuctioneers Logo
Online Auctions
Matthews Auctions, LLC
Rick Bonenberger Estate Auction #1 - Day 2
Montana Chief Gasoline w/Logo Porcelain Identification Sign (TAC)Rare Mohawk Gasoline w/Logo Metal Sign (TAC)Red Hat Motor Oil Gasoline w/Logo & Independent Oil Porcelain Sign (30)(TAC)
Done
Waterloo, WI, United States
Auction Details

Rick Bonenberger Estate Auction #1 - Day 2

Matthews Auctions, LLC

Matthews Auctions, LLC

badge TOP RATED
This is the first Auction for the Bonenberger Estate out of Evansville, IN. We are going to be selling a large assortment of items over the course of 2 days, so be sure to view the full catalog that is now posted and get to bidding. On-Site Bidding at 500 Park Ave. Waterloo, WI 53594 and online bidding through our platform, there is also Phone and absentee bidding available. Reach out to Dan at 217-259-7059 or Cyrus at 920-350-5533 with any questions.
LiveAuctioneers Purchase Protection
Get the confidence you need to bid on the items you love.Learn More
Complete payment via LiveAuctioneers to qualify.
Bidding Options: This is a Live / Onsite Auction with Phone, Absentee & Online Bidding through multiple platforms as well.? Live Auction held at 500 Park Ave. Waterloo, WI 53594 You can leave a Phone Bid or
0001: Bidding OptionsEst. $50-$200,000Lot Passed
Payment Info: Onsite Bidding - You pay with cash, good check or Credit Card the day of the auction and you can leave with your product.? Phone / Absentee Bidding- You will get an invoice emailed to you within 3
0002: Payment InfoEst. $50-$200,000Lot Passed
Shipping / Pickup: All Items are of shipable size and will be shipped by default unless we are told differently. We do all of our shipping in house as cheap as possible. You will receive a message from our system
0003: Shipping / PickupEst. $50-$200,000Lot Passed
Authentic / Original Items: All items in this auction are authentic unless it says "Reproduction" or "Fantasy" in the title or description. Reproduction is a exact copy of the original item Fantasy item was
0004: Authentic / Original ItemsEst. $50-$200,000Lot Passed
Sold
Bisonoil w/Buffalo Logo One-Quart Round Metal Can: rated 9, the one-quart round metal can, crimped seam, has good color and shine, has light wear, is empty, opened on bottom. Rarity 6. TAC #060750
2001: Bisonoil w/Buffalo Logo One-Quart Round Metal CanEst. $50-$200,000
Sold
Polly Penn Motor Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal Can: rated 8.9 & 8.5, the one-quart round metal can soldered seam, has good color and shine, has light wear, reverse has a little more, is empty, opened on top. Rarity 5. TAC #060747
2002: Polly Penn Motor Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal CanEst. $50-$200,000
Sold
Ace High Motor Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal Can: rated 9+, the one-quart round metal can soldered seam, has good color and shine, has light wear, is empty, opened on top. Rarity 7. TAC #060749
2003: Ace High Motor Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal CanEst. $50-$200,000
Sold
Rare Around the World Motor Oil w/Logo One Quart Round Metal Can: rated 8.75 & 7.5, the one-quart round metal can has crimped seam, has good color and some shine, display has light wear, minor mark, and ding at the top edge, reverse large area of paint loss, is
2004: Rare Around the World Motor Oil w/Logo One Quart Round Metal CanEst. $50-$200,000
Sold
Sky Ranger Aviation Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal Can: rated 9, the one-quart round metal can with crimped seam, has good color and shine, has light wear, small ding in the upper field, is full, is original not redone. Rarity 7. TAC #060751
2005: Sky Ranger Aviation Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal CanEst. $50-$200,000
Sold
Caspar Motorcycle Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal Can (TAC): rated 8.75, the one-quart round metal can has soldered seam, has good color and shine, has minor soiling and dings, minor scratches around the top edge, is full. Rarity 8. TAC #060764
2006: Caspar Motorcycle Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal Can (TAC)Est. $50-$200,000
Sold
Sea Gull Motor Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal Can: rated 9, the one-quart round metal can, has crimped seam, has very good color and shine, is empty, light wear. Rarity 6. TAC #060752
2007: Sea Gull Motor Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal CanEst. $50-$200,000
Sold
Skyway Motor Oil w/DC-3 Image One-Quart Round Metal Can: rated 8.9 & 6.5, the one quart round metal can with soldered seam, has good color and shine, display has light wear, reverse has large area of paint loss, is full. Rarity 7. TAC #060753
2008: Skyway Motor Oil w/DC-3 Image One-Quart Round Metal CanEst. $50-$200,000
Sold
Wil-Fo Motor Oil w/Car in Winter Scene One-Quart Round Metal Can (TAC): rated 9.5, the one-quart round metal can has soldered seam, has excellent color and shine, nice, is full. Rarity 7. TAC #060761
2009: Wil-Fo Motor Oil w/Car in Winter Scene One-Quart Round Metal Can (TAC)Est. $50-$200,000
Sold
Supreme Compounded Motor Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal Can: rated 8.5, the one-quart round metal can has soldered seam, has good color and shine, has small dents, is full. Rarity 6. TAC #060755
2010: Supreme Compounded Motor Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal CanEst. $50-$200,000
Sold
Penn-Bee Motor Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal Can (TAC): rated 9.25, the one-quart round metal can has soldered seam, has excellent color and shine, very minor wear if any, is full. Rarity 5. TAC #060759
2011: Penn-Bee Motor Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal Can (TAC)Est. $50-$200,000
Sold
Penn-Bee Motor Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal Can (TAC): rated 8.9, the one-quart round metal can with crimped seam, has good color and shine, has light wear, is full, top has light rust. Rarity 5. TAC #060760
2012: Penn-Bee Motor Oil w/Logo One-Quart Round Metal Can (TAC)Est. $50-$200,000
Sold
Pennsylvania Motor Oil w/Image One-Quart Round Metal Can: rated 9, the one-quart round metal can with crimped seam, has excellent color and shine, is full, has dent in the back. Rarity 5. TAC #060754
2013: Pennsylvania Motor Oil w/Image One-Quart Round Metal CanEst. $50-$200,000
Sold
Penntroleum Motor Oil w/Boat Scene One-Quart Round Metal Can (TAC): rated 9, the one-quart round metal can has soldered seam, has very good color and shine, very light wear, has minor dings around the top, is full. Rarity 5. TAC #060763
2014: Penntroleum Motor Oil w/Boat Scene One-Quart Round Metal Can (TAC)Est. $50-$200,000
Sold
Panhandle Panolene Motor Oil w/Logo Quart Metal Can: rated 9+, the one quart round metal can with crimped seam, has been re-lided, is empty.
2015: Panhandle Panolene Motor Oil w/Logo Quart Metal CanEst. $50-$200,000
Sold
Vulcan "The Replacement Spring" w/Image Metal Sign (TAC): rated 7.5, 19.75"x27.25", the SST embossed sign has good color and shine, has wear and fine scratches in the field, has staining along the left-hand edge, marked Novelty Adv. Rarity 9. TAC
2016: Vulcan "The Replacement Spring" w/Image Metal Sign (TAC)Est. $50-$200,000
Sold
Quaker City Motor Oil Metal Sign (TAC): rated 9, 18.75"x12.75", the SST embossed sign has good color and shine, field is clean, has wear along the bottom. Rarity 4. TAC #060853
2017: Quaker City Motor Oil Metal Sign (TAC)Est. $50-$200,000
Sold
Harbor Super Gasoline Ethyl w/Logo Metal Pump Sign (TAC): rated 7, 19.75"x13.75", the SST embossed pump sign has notable wear with deep scratching and soiling. Marked Scioto. Rarity 9.TAC #060856
2018: Harbor Super Gasoline Ethyl w/Logo Metal Pump Sign (TAC)Est. $50-$200,000
Sold
Harbor Regular Gasoline Metal Pump Sign (TAC): rated 6.5, 15.75"x13.75", the SST embossed pump sign, has staining in the logo. Rarity 9. TAC #060857
2019: Harbor Regular Gasoline Metal Pump Sign (TAC)Est. $50-$200,000
Sold
Quickure "When I have a Leak in my Radiator" Metal Sign (TAC): rated 8.5, 11"x9.75", the SST sign has good color and shine, has light paper marks, the bottom has been bent around to make it stand up, it was made to stick down inside the display box in the back.
2020: Quickure "When I have a Leak in my Radiator" Metal Sign (TAC)Est. $50-$200,000

Auction Details

Matthews Auctions, LLC

Matthews Auctions, LLC

badge TOP RATED
Nokomis, IL, United States
160 Reviews
2,507 Followers
Bid Increments
PriceBid Increment
$0$25
$300$50
$700$100
$2,000$250
$5,000$500
$13,000$1,000
$25,000$2,500
Preview
2 Hours before the auction each day and February 4th all day
500 Park Ave
Waterloo, WI 53594
USA
Buyer's Premium
  • 20%
Terms & Conditions
20% Online Bidding through Live Auctioneers plus the LA credit card fee. 18% on Matthews Platform with cash or check. See Lots 1 - 4 for additional info
 
Autopay
If you have not contacted Matthews Auctions, LLC to arrange payment within 1 day of the time that invoice is sent, we will charge the credit card you used to register for the auction for the amount of your invoice.
 
Sales Tax
Online purchases from Matthews Auctions, LLC may be subject to sales tax. Please see the following for more details. If you are tax-exempt, you can submit your tax-exempt certificate to prevent the collection of tax. Learn more about tax-exemption.
Â