Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers, NY - Read over 147 Reviews from Customers
LiveAuctioneers Logo

Bidder Reviews for Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers (147)

4.1 out of 5.0 Stars

100-147 of 147 Reviews

All Ratings
Highest Rated

Sabine
Huguenot, NY

Jun 13, 2020
Professional Service
Great Estates Auctioneers is a well run auction house. The owner is honest with his appraisals and was very responsive to my questions as well as accommodating me with pick up times. Highly recommended.
Report
ANTIQUE FANCY STERLING SILVER SMALLS LOT

Avelino
El Cerrito, CA

Jun 13, 2020
CHINESE SILVER JADEITE & CRYSTAL RING

Steven
Crown Point, IN

May 10, 2020

Joseph
Richboro, PA

May 09, 2020

Michael
Rancho Cucamonga, CA

Mar 28, 2020
Nicely
Fair
Report
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersMar 28, 2020
Customer purchased an item at a Great Price. Apparently expected free shipping and handling. Unfortunately there are costs involved. Questions should be addressed before bidding.
VINTAGE ELECTRICIAN METAL ADVERTISING FLANGE SIGN

Eric
Gaithersburg, MD

Mar 28, 2020
Excellent experience
Very good experience, thank you!!
Report
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersMar 28, 2020
Thank you Eric. We appreciate your business.
MOROZ - MONUMENTAL MYTHS OF ANCIENT GREECE CABINET

Arden
Laguna Hills, CA

Feb 17, 2020
Charged over 2x the Actual Shipping/Packing Costs
Bought a painting unframed and was charged $100 for shipping even though the box cost $2 and the packing which was just one layer of bubble wrap cost me $100. Actual shipping charges were $35 + $3 in packing. To make matters worse... they stuck their label on the painted side of the canvas.
Report
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersFeb 18, 2020
Buyer's claims are false. Item was packed as a courtesy, per his request. Customer had an Oversized Box shipped across the country. We do not set freight charges. Arash is completely unaware of materials costs or shipping costs. We serve thousands of customers, unfortunately false claims like this arise. We have an email from this customer stating the painting arrived fine.
PENEKE - PROMINENT GATHERING PAINTING

valerie
New York, NY

Feb 15, 2020
They give other auction houses a bad name!!!!!
I won a small runner (rug) at their auction. It took several phone calls + emails to even get them to respond so I might pay. I then arranged for shipping. They charged me FIFTY DOLLARS and when the rug arrived, it said $25.00 on their shipping cost. Avoid them at all costs!!! I'd had a really great experience with another auction house several weeks before. I had won a much larger rug and their shipper sent it quickly for $30.00!!!!
Report
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersFeb 18, 2020
We are sorry this customer is unhappy with the wonderful rug purchased at such an incredible price. We are sorry she chose to call during non business hours. Unfortunately she did not understand the postage/packing fee correctly. We process thousands of transactions without any issues. $25.00 to ship to Park Ave New York City is quite reasonable. Just a shame to receive this kind of reaction. Buyer should have picked the item up.
CAUCASIAN SCATTER RUG

JAMES
Lexington, MO

Feb 15, 2020
GROUP OF 6 AMERICAN INDIAN POTTERY MINIATURES

Matthew
Alexandria, VA

Feb 15, 2020
shipping rate
I would like to see a commercial shipping rate.
Report
VENUS ADVERTISING DISPLAY CASE WITH PENCILS

Lolly
RYE, NY

Feb 15, 2020
HELEN FRANKENTHALER - ABSTRACT SIGNED ETCHING

robert
New Fairfield, CT

Feb 15, 2020
WW2 BATTLE OF THE BULGE AMERICAN STAR FIELD MARKER

Joe
Naples, FL

Feb 15, 2020
WINCHESTER MODEL 37 12 GAUGE SHOTGUN RIFLE

Ronald
Largo, FL

Dec 28, 2019
Nice itme
Great transaction
Report
HAWKES STERLING LIDDED CUT CRYSTAL CANDY JAR

C
Columbia, MD

Nov 29, 2019
Been waiting over a month for my item...
Would not recommend
Report
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersDec 04, 2019
Item was mailed a month ago. We are checking with the shipper to have this resolved asap. Customer just notified us of non receipt. Unfair review.
RUSSIAN KGB MILITARY WATERPROOF DIVERS WRISTWATCH

Philip
Washington, NC

Nov 17, 2019
Had concern about bidiing-While watching auction someone kept bidiing against me. I was outbid.
I was outbid in auction only to find out latter that I won the item. I have heard that some auction houses use false bidders to bring up prices. Shipping was excessive. Probably will not bid with this Auction house in the future.
Report
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersNov 19, 2019
Auctions do involve bidding. Bidder was not outbid. Shipping was extremely reasonable. Customer is unreasonable.
LUDWIG EISENBERGER - VICTORIOUS GLADIATOR BRONZE

Alyson
Oswego, NY

Nov 17, 2019

Steven
Houston, TX

Nov 17, 2019
DiNOVI - NUDE BLONDE PORTRAIT PAINTING

Patrick
Nashville, TN

Nov 16, 2019
Accurate pictures, prompt shipping and item well protected.
Accurate pictures, prompt shipping and item well protected.
Report
PELIKAN TITANIUM SILVER MECHANICAL BALL POINT PEN

Tim
Tower Lakes, IL

Aug 23, 2019
CHINESE IMPERIAL JADE GREEN GLAZED BULBOUS VASE

Charles
Lakeside, CA

May 15, 2019
REMINGTON STYLE INDIAN WARRIORS PAINTING

William
Phoenix, AZ

May 08, 2019
Poor Experience
Here's an accurate account of my experience, judge for yourself. There were no initial bidders so the price dropped to around $50. I then started bidding, and after a long pause, another bid popped up. This happened in $10 increments until I bid $200. At that time, an opposing bid came in for $210 and I dropped out. I was surprised to be notified via email that I had won the item for $200. Don't know what happened to the $210 bidder. Hmm. I next heard from the shipper chosen by Great Estates. They charged an exorbitant amount for shipping-over $165 to pack and ship a vase. I've shipped and received many many similar items, and this cost is off the charts. I complained to Great Estates and they basically advised me to pick my own shipper next time. I just received the vase, and there is a large, ugly repair of a large portion of the ceramic decorative element, unmentioned in the initial catalog. In my opinion, Great Estates is a dishonest organization and LiveAuctioneers should rethink allowing them to put their own reputation at risk.
Report
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersMay 09, 2019
This was a simple clerking error. In house bidding becomes quite fast at times. Buyer requested assistance for shipping, which was arranged as a service to him. Item was extremely fragile and difficult to pack. Customer has no inclination of labor involved, should appreciate the shipping company. Item was not repaired. Auction houses beware of buyer.
IMPERIAL AMPHORA PORCELAIN GILT PUTTI BASKET

Errol
Sherman, CT

May 07, 2019
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersMay 10, 2019
Condition reports are available upon request. Some items of age may have slight imperfections.
GERMAN TAN MILITARY NAZI AIRPLANE REPLICA

Timoty
Saint Louis, MO

May 06, 2019
Slow to respond
slow to respond to requests for information and shipping. Won't bid with them again.
Report
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersMay 06, 2019
Customer failed to read his invoice regarding our shipping policy. We responded to his inpatient inquires in a timely manner. An outside shipping company handled his item as a courtesy arranged by us. Issues with an outside company, not us.
ADMIRAL DEWEY - BATTLE OF MANILA CHROMOLITHOGRAPH

Charles
Scottsdale, AZ

May 04, 2019
Misleading description
Listing says "excellent" condition and the pens are certainly not that. One is broken and totally useless. They all were shipped with ink cartridges installed which then requires that I remove the cartridges and flush the pens. Plus, ridiculous add-on charges so in the end, this is not a good buy at all. Do not recommend this auction at all.
Report
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersMay 06, 2019
Items were excellent as shown in the pictures. Why would someone flush the ink out of a pen? Talk about ridiculous... items sold for a bargain price, we packed and transported them as a service, gave customer a discount and he still isn't happy. False claims, other auction houses beware of bidder.
QUALITY WRITING INSTRUMENTS PEN LOT

John
West Columbia, SC

May 04, 2019
INTERCHANGABLE LEVENGER MARBLE ROLLER BALL PEN

Michael
Raymond, CA

May 02, 2019
Reasonableshipping charge packed by them
You can buy smalls and not be overcharged on shipping.
Report
ARTISAN STERLING MUSTANGS HORSE BOLO SIGNED ALS

peter
Sarasota, FL

Mar 17, 2019
CHINESE CARVED STONE BUDDHA HEAD

Rio
Golden, CO

Mar 16, 2019
I spoke with a very nice gentleman.
Report
TWO 14K YELLOW GOLD NECKLACE PENDANTS

Mar 13, 2019
LUXURIOUS FLEMINGTON FURS SILVER FOX & MINK COAT

John R.
Phoenix, AZ

Mar 03, 2019
RELIGIOUS MADONNA & CHILD OLD MASTER PAINTING

Michael
Danville, CA

Mar 02, 2019
LEVENGER MARBLE MECHANICAL ROLLER BALL PEN

Steven
Bethel, NY

Feb 26, 2019
ART DECO 10K YELLOW GOLD DIAMOND & ONYX RING

Jeff
Houston, TX

Feb 04, 2019
J.R. RICHARDSON - SOUTHWESTERN LANDSCAPE PAINTING

Jim
Lynden, WA

Dec 30, 2018
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersApr 04, 2019
Item was listed as seen. No false claims were made.
VICTORIAN PHOTO ALBUM W/ INDIAN PICTURES

James
Kaneohe, HI

Dec 29, 2018
WORLD WAR II USS BITTERN BRONZE BATTLESHIP BELL

Rui
Garden Grove, CA

Dec 29, 2018
CHINESE CH'ING SILVER JADE LOTUS BRACELET EARRINGS

Mary
Alexandria, VA

Dec 29, 2018
J. CHALFIN - FRUIT STILL LIFE WATERCOLOR

Sylvana Marie
Montreal, CA

Oct 17, 2018
Allow me to give a friendly suggestion. To deal with the public or the clients the e Auction House should assign this delicate and so important job to someone who has good manners Unfortunately I had to deal with rude and unpolite employee. Best, Sylvana Marie
Report
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersApr 04, 2019
Buyer was quite difficult to deal with. Buyer refused to follow payment instructions, finally directed her to call liveauctioneers after her refusal to work with us. Unfortunately, this false review is quite the contrary.

Anonymous

Jun 01, 2018
I'm 80 years and get rather confused, at times, with the computer world. I talked with "JC" twice about the shipping buying/Shipping process.......... He is a highly worthy representative for your company, when it comes to confused older folks. He guided me with grace. Blessings, Maxwell
Report
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersApr 04, 2019
Thank you . We appreciate your business. Blessings to you as well. JC

Anonymous

May 29, 2018

Anonymous

Jul 27, 2017
I have paid them in full for my items and indicated I will need info to arrange shipping. I have emailed them and telephoned them requesting status of my items and shipping info and they have not responded. They have had my payment in full for more than two weeks! I would appreciate any help from you to resolve this. My invoice is **********. Thanks for your help.
Report

Anonymous

Jul 26, 2017
To Many Hoops to jump thru for Payment & Shipping. Maybe we that live in the Midwest, find Auction companies easier and more trusting perhaps? But then I'm just an old man that still does business w/a handshake.
Report

Anonymous

Jul 26, 2017
They need to answer their phone and make better arrangements for shipping. It was only recently that the items purchased several weeks ago we're finally shipped after many phone calls and messages that were left unanswered.
Report
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersApr 04, 2019
We gladly answer calls. Shipping is provided as a service on your behalf. Customers constant inquiries delayed the process.

Anonymous

Aug 16, 2016
I still do not see that they charged my card for payment and they told me shipping will be separate charge but not sure what is the amount. Yet I see that LiveAuctioneers is showing payment due. Over all not very satisfied. I dealt with pretty good number and that is not the best experience so far.
Report

Anonymous

Feb 21, 2016
February 1st & 2nd: I was invoiced on the 1st and I paid on the 2nd, using their online payment forms. February 10th: I got a 'PAST DUE' notice. I wrote, and they responded saying it was an oversight and they'd take care of it, as I needed shipping. On the 18th, I finally got a very hard to read invoice for extremely expensive packing and shipping since it was 'in-state' and a small item. The item was put in a small flat rate Priority Mail box, when a regular Priority box would have cost $10 less, plus they charged for taking it to the Post Office, when the Post Office picks up for free. (They used the PO online for Postage) February 20th: I finally received my lot and it's nothing short of a miracle that it arrived undamaged because the box was far too small for the size of the item, and it was shoddily packed. The invoice for the shipping claimed "CUSTOM PACKING, MATERIALS, TRANSPORT"... custom packing is a JOKE! USED BUBBLE WRAP? Very, very poor service.... for everything. Harvey
Report
Great Estates Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Great Estates Auctioneers & AppraisersMay 13, 2019
Harvey received his item undamaged due to our custom packing. Harvey did not understand the time involved to take care of his item. Harvey has very very poor manners.

Anonymous

Feb 15, 2016
I am unable to fully evaluate at this time as I have not received items. They require payment before they will ship. Also they notified me that they will send a separate invoice for shipping before shipping.
Report
View:
50
TOP