Brooks Auction , NJ - Read over 127 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Brooks Auction (127)

4.4 out of 5.0 Stars

1-50 of 127 Reviews

DAVID
Canton, OH

Apr 21, 2026
Easy transaction and willingness to assist
Good bidding experience and transaction
Report
Assortment of Model and Toy Vehicles

Clint
Ridgecrest, CA

Apr 18, 2026
Lot of Coca Cola Collectible Toy Vehicles

Mostafa
Barrington, IL

Apr 01, 2026
Vintage Oriental Accent Rug

Murray
Mannsville, OK

Mar 23, 2026
Good folks to work with. Shipping was expensive using USPS through Pak Mail.
Good folks to work with. Shipping was expensive using USPS through Pak Mail. This was the shipping option still cheaper than liveauction. My 4 items weighed 13 lbs. in a box about12 "x12" x16 . I paid $44 for lot that's including all fees and paid another $71 for shipping. I am only showing this for transparency for out of state folks that wonder how much shipping would be. Also I did not request anything to be sent quickly as I was seeking the best shipping deal I could get. I will says its disappointing to pay almost double shipping than what my lot cost. Just have to figure this in when bidding. This in the end is on myself as i was in control of my bidding and I hold nothing against auction house because they were kind enough to help with the 3rd party shipping.
Report
Lot of Vintage First Day Stamp Covers

Murray
Mannsville, OK

Mar 20, 2026
First of all good folks. Bad USPS handling of my package. Not auction folks fault.
Great auction folks. Thank you for helping me out. As for USPS, they delivered my package that looked like it had been in a wreck and taped back up several times. Thank god the auction folks put my items in gallon ziplock bags which saved my items from being scattered across several states. The box was so badly damaged I could put a hand through three holes ripped but the gallon bags were too large to fall out. Overall I was not missing anything or no contents damaged so I guess USPS got off lucky on this one. By no means let this keep you from using these folks, they were nothing but helpful and i was whole in the end so no harm no foul.
Report
Collection of Vintage Stamps

Richard
New York, NY

Feb 24, 2026
Two Vintage Pressed Steel Tow Trucks

Hector
Salinas, CA

Feb 17, 2026
N/A
N/A
Report
c.1940's-50's Kellogg's Red Metal Cereal Advertising Display

Robert
Dixon, IL

Jan 28, 2026
Antique Radioptican No. 441 H.C. White & Co Postcard Projector

joseph
Cranesville, PA

Jan 05, 2026
buyer beware
bought a lot, they lied to me and said they accidently added coins to a coinbook then never sent them, said they would refund me cas they sold my item in another lot, but they still charged me shipping and auction fees for the item they never sent me, im out money and they are not trustworthy
Report
Five Coin Books

Maureen
Pasadena, CA

Dec 30, 2025
Auctioneer failed to disclose significant damage to carvings
Photographs noted minor damage to ark but failed to depict significant damage to 33 of 38 carved animals included. Admittedly I could have inquired prior to bidding but honestly, this big a miss almost feels intentional. There were photos of the minor damage to the ark, which is to be expected of an old wooden toy, but only one group photo of the animals where it was impossible to discern the extent of the damage. I have never even seen an antique ark toy where so many animals were damaged... of course, as with the ark some damage is expected but nothing like this. The value of this old toy has been significantly compromised by the damage and I feel a bit taken advantage of.
Report
Antique Wooden Model Toy Noah's Ark

Douglas
Mesquite, TX

Nov 12, 2025
Three Vintage Broadway Playbills w/ Autographs incl. Sandy Dennis & Jack Gilford

Tim
Fort Collins, CO

Oct 26, 2025
two beautiful wall clocks and a fantastic Grandfather clock.
these clocks add simplicity to my collection. Thanks a lot.
Report
Seth Thomas Clock Co. "Queen Anne" Wall Clock

Eric
New York, NY

Oct 24, 2025
Simple auction, cleanly handled
Auction house did a good job packaging and sending item, had no issues at all. Recommended.
Report
Globe Wernicke Oak File Drawer

Joseph
Knoxville, TN

Oct 15, 2025
Antique Brass Wall Mounted Ship's Clock

Clay
Arvada, CO

Oct 14, 2025
John Deere Tractor Bank

Roy
Pittsburgh, PA

Sep 19, 2025
Anvil

BRIAN
Lodi, CA

Sep 19, 2025
WHAT A SEAMLESS PROCESS FROM BEGINNING TO END ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
THIS WAS ONE OF THE FINEST EXPERIENCES THAT I HAVE EVER HAD WITH AN ONLINE AUCTION COMPANY SUCH AS: RECEIVED AS DESCRIBED AND FAST; FAST COMMUNICATION RESPONSES WHEN CONTACTED; VERY REASONABLE SHIPPING COST; PROFESSIONAL CUSTOMER SERVICE REPRESENTATIVES (CARAH WAS MY CONTACT); ETC., ETC. HIGHEST RECOMMENDATION
Report
50's Fisher Price "Talking Donald Duck" Pull Toy

Roy
Harrison, NY

Sep 16, 2025
very professonal
great people, easy to do business with
Report
Vintage David Hamberger Attributed Christmas Elf Display

Donna
Westfield, MA

Sep 16, 2025
A wonderful experience.
Very pleased with all the information given and the personal help with shipping. Will be happy to place bids again. Thank you.
Report
Vintage 50's Ideal Shirley Temple Doll w/ Original Box & Accessories

brian
Schenectady, NY

Sep 16, 2025
Vintage 1982 Margarete Steiff Giengen Bear Mohair Collectors Edition 0203/00

Tibisay
Miami, FL

Sep 11, 2025
I never received my item
I paid for the painting, they told me that they were going to send it to me from a third party, I wrote like 5 times to the supposed shipping company and they never answered me, until now I just waited.
Report
Vintage Lion Oil Painting in Ornate Gold Toned Frame

Bob
Commerce Township, MI

Sep 09, 2025
Rocking Horse with Clown Rider Antique Glass Candy Container

Aaron
Knoxville, TN

Sep 09, 2025
Watch out for bid limit.
I had planned on buying several items at the recent Brooks auction. Unfortunately, I was unaware that they had issued a $400 bid cap on me meaning that the most I could bid in total was $400. The card I have on file has a max of $20, 000 so this makes no sense to me.. The items that I had planned on bidding on added up to several thousand in value so I was unable to bid on most items. I did win one lot and it was packed and shipped professionally. If you choose to participate in one of their auctions be very observant so that you are able to bid on what you want. I assume that if you see the limit, you can have it lifted.
Report
Lot of Assorted Antique Glass Novelty Candy Containers

brian
Schenectady, NY

Aug 19, 2025
Vintage Mattel Barbie "Busy Morning" #956 Set

Debra
Reno, NV

Aug 18, 2025
Vintage Floral Patterned Hooked Rug

James
Mifflinburg, PA

Aug 12, 2025
HOPE TO HAVE MORE EXPERIENCES WITH THIS AUCTION COMPANY
EXCELLENT SERVICE
Report
Rustic & Primitives Assortment ft. Butter Molds

Dennis
Fletcher, NC

Aug 10, 2025
timely service
very good service!!!!!!!!!
Report
1949 Smith Miller MN-40 GMC Wrecker #401-W

Robyn
Yerington, NV

Jul 29, 2025
Vintage 1960's Ideal Tiny Thumbelina Original Doll in Box

Sean
Wayne, NJ

Jul 29, 2025
Great to deal with
Went to pick the items up. Everyone was very helpful and courteous. Would bid with them again.
Report
Lot of Vintage Vinyl Records Featuring The Beatles

Clint
Ridgecrest, CA

Jul 25, 2025
Smith-Miller "Smitty Toy" Coca Cola Truck/Wooden Body

Amy
Austin, TX

Jul 23, 2025
Lovely Lalique piece!
I LOVE this piece! She arrived with some scratches and dings, but I LOVE her still. She has a prominent place in my Lalique cabinet and am very glad I made this purchase. She's been well "loved" and will continue in my care.
Report
Lalique Art Deco Frosted Glass Female Figural Flower Frog

Kelli
Auburndale, FL

Jul 22, 2025
Excellent Items, Excellent Service
Excellent Item, Excellent Service Thank you
Report
Western Plains Barbie in original box

Tony
Ramsgate, GB

Jul 15, 2025
Vintage Lucite Purse Covered With Woven Pattern

Larry
Winnemucca, NV

Jul 01, 2025
Vintage Sterling Silver Watch Pin

Greg
Franklin, TN

Jul 01, 2025
Ten Confederate Era Bills and Assorted Currency

anthony
Hammonton, NJ

Jun 30, 2025
Lot of Antique Glassware Featuring Whitall-Tatum Co.

Kevin
Wetumpka, AL

Jun 30, 2025
Excellent auction company
I’ve done business with over hundred auction companies. Without a doubt this company is one of the best I would participate in their auctions without hesitation.
Report
Madame Alexander "Mop Top Wendy" Doll in original box

Timothy
Lees Summit, MO

Jun 18, 2025
WWII 90 MM Inert M-12 Drill Cartridge

Mark
Lewiston, ME

Jun 05, 2025
Christmas
Would bid with this Auction house again, very good experience overall.
Report
Vintage Christmas Decor Assortment Lot

Dennis
Fletcher, NC

Jun 05, 2025
service
Good communication
Report
Limited Fred T. Smith Miller Howard Sommers Wrecker Truck #56/250

Robert
Willoughby, OH

Jun 04, 2025
Metalcraft Standard Oil Pressed Steel Toy Truck

PATRICIA
Belleview, FL

May 31, 2025
Early Small Shaker Bottle "Shaker Anodyne Nth Enfield, NH"

Jorge
Shreveport, LA

May 27, 2025
Pioneer PL-7 Vintage Turntable

Robert
Dixon, IL

May 16, 2025
Five Vintage Celluloid Santa Figurines

Zach
Pittsbugh, PA

May 13, 2025
Antique Folk Art Articulated Tin Toy

Melinda
Carson, CA

May 06, 2025
Disney Dollar Series Celebrate You & Pirates of the Caribbean

Keyla
Jacksonville, FL

Apr 30, 2025
Great service
Called to inquired about my item. The lady who talked to me was very helpful and answered all my questions. She encouraged me to download the Brooks app, which I did, and is much better. Thank you.
Report
Madame Alexander Cinderella 1536 Doll in Box

Tim
Fort Collins, CO

Mar 27, 2025
it is up and running as we speak. Great addition to my collection
This Brass Clock works well. Thanks for participating in the auction process.
Report
Weems & Plath Brass Nautical Wall Clock

Bob
Wilmington, DE

Mar 25, 2025
Three Antique Local Glass Bottles

Thomas
Easley, SC

Mar 11, 2025
Easy process and shipping
The entire process was easy. Questions were answered accurately. Shipping was no problem at all.
Report
Oxford College All Souls Common Room Antique Wine Bottle