Modern Jewelry, CA - Read over 204 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Modern Jewelry (204)

4.4 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 204 Reviews

Mason
Chicago, IL

Feb 03, 2026
They sold me a COUNTERFEIT Tag Heuer Model: CJF2114, Serial #: VC2115
They sold me a counterfeit Tag Heuer, online search says the following: VC 2115 is a well known counterfeited watch serial number for model # CJF2114. Of course they wouldn't show the numbers and there was no box, only an Asian booklet. They also wanted to charge me over $300 for shipping a FAKE WATCH. To make matters worse they wanted to charge me over $300 to safely ship and insure a fake watch.
Report
TAG HEUER LINK CHRONOGRAPH CJF2114 MEN'S WATCH

o c
Hardeeville, SC

Jan 11, 2026
live auctioneers
never again live auctioneers
Report
HERMES COLLIER DE CHIEN BANGLE RED

Kim
Brooklyn, NY

Dec 28, 2025
Pre-owned sterling silver gold plated chain

Anthony
Brooklyn, NY

Dec 04, 2025
MAATCHING PAIR 5MM NATURAL TURQUOISE

Suzanne
Minneapolis, MN

Nov 19, 2025
NEW 14K YELLOW GOLD SMALL HORSE PENDANT

Don
Spring Lake, NJ

Oct 17, 2025
Fully disclosed-lovely watch
There is a tiny, REALLY tiny flaw in the watch, which was disclosed with photos that if anything, made it look much worse than it really is. The watch is running perfectly, and the flaw doesn't really effect how nice the watch is. 5 stars for this auctioneer!
Report
MEN'S BULOVA STAINLESS STEEL WATCH 35MM 96D18

Mary Lou
Bronx, NY

Oct 07, 2025
STERLING SILVER HEAVY DOMED OMEGA CHOKER NECKLACE

Gary
Seattle, WA

Oct 06, 2025
you made it all easy, thanks
one of the easiest transactions I've had w/any auction house
Report
TAXCO STERLING SILVER MEXICO BLACK ONYX GEMSTONE CLIP-ON EARRINGS 1.75"

Holly
Montreal, CA

Oct 02, 2025
So far so good!
I havent received my items yet, but in general have found the auction house easy to deal with. I made a mistake in my shipping address and my package was returned to them after a month of being in the post. Once we figured out the mistake, they were quick to help me fix it and offered to re-ship the items as long as I paid for the shipping, which feels fair. I'm really looking forward to getting the items and I think they look really beautiful and unique based on the pictures online.
Report
NEW 14K YELLOW GOLD SMALL ROUND TUBE HOOP EARRINGS

AnnMarie
Summit, NJ

Sep 18, 2025
Modern Jewelry worked with me to resolve my concerns.
Modern Jewelry worked with me to resolve my concerns. I am grateful for their responsiveness and consideration. The shipping issues are not their fault. LiveAuctioneers forces the auction house to work with a specific shipper and this is delaying getting orders out the door.
Report
NEW 14K WHITE GOLD HOOP TUBE EARRINGS 3mm

Lu Jer
Taipei City, TW

Sep 04, 2025
MORGAN STYLE 4 TROY OZ .999 FINE SILVER BULLION ROUND

Alisa
Dix Hills, NY

Jul 14, 2025
VINTAGE STAINLESS STEEL CURB CHAIN  24"

Laurie
Los Angeles, CA

Jun 30, 2025
14K YELLOW GOLD LADIES GIRLS ROUND HUGGIE HOOP EARRINGS

Gregory
Land O Lakes, FL

Jun 28, 2025
great Auction house. customers first.
thanks
Report
14K YELLOW GOLD STAR OF DAVID PENDANT 4.2 GRAMS

Mark
Key West, FL

Jun 12, 2025
OVAL CABOCHON BLOOD RED NATURAL CORAL

Matt
Miami Beach, FL

Jun 10, 2025
STERLING SILVER SNAKE BRACELET

Pauline
Brooklyn, NY

Jun 10, 2025
Extremely pleased. Good deal.
Extremely Satisfied. I made a beautiful ring with this gemstone. Good deal.
Report
NEW 5.8ct LARGE NEW CUSHION CUT SYNTHETIC RUBY

Fred
Las Vegas, NV

Jun 10, 2025
Pictures not even close to the actual rings
Sadly what was presented was not even close to the actual rings. One of the at least looked good but the other looked like it was a gag ring. When I contacted them (because I actually thought they made a delivery mistake because it took a month to get the rings), I complained about the clear bait n switch they pulled on me. Their response was I could return the rings (which was very nice of them to offer that-with a full refund too!-again very nice!) but i chose to keep them because I just didnt want to go thru the hassle. Oh they also made a complaint that at the price of gold right now, they lost money on the deal. Not sure if they get that this is an auction site and thats the risk they took but in reality, I did weigh them and they were the weight they advertised-just not the look of the picture. Wish them well but not again for me
Report
Modern Jewelry logo
Modern JewelryJun 10, 2025
First and foremost, we sincerely apologize for any inconvenience caused during this transaction. The buyer purchased two gold nugget rings and selected ACH as the payment method. As noted during checkout on LiveAuctioneers, ACH payments typically take 7 – 10 business days to clear. This process was slightly delayed due to a holiday weekend and standard shipping time. Regarding the rings, the buyer received exactly what was listed — two genuine gold nugget rings. It’s important to note that nugget rings are unique by nature, meaning no two are identical in appearance, which is part of their inherent design and appeal. The buyer raised a concern that the rings might not weigh as much as advertised. We responded promptly and encouraged them to weigh the items. After doing so, the buyer found the rings actually exceeded the listed weight. In fact, given the high price of gold at the time, the buyer realized they had received more gold value than what was paid. Despite this, we offered a full refund, even though it would have resulted in a loss on our end. After confirming the weight and value, the buyer chose to keep the rings and expressed satisfaction. We took the buyer’s concerns seriously and responded quickly and professionally. Our commitment is always to honesty, fair dealing, and customer satisfaction. We regret any misunderstanding.
NEW 14K YELLOW GOLD MEN'S NUGGET RING

James
Herndon, VA

Mar 25, 2025
CONVERSE CHINATOWN MARKET BATMAN CHUCK 70 HI BLACK MENS SNEAKERS

maria
Warren, NJ

Mar 15, 2025
fast
quick service and process handling
Report
AUTHENTIC GUCCI STAINLESS STEEL LOGO CLIP WATCH 9100L 3ATM DATE 24MM WRISTWATCH

geraldine
Santa Barbara, CA

Mar 11, 2025
A.STONEWALL & CO. STERLING SILVER CHRYSANTHEMUM LADLE SERVING SPOON - 7.75"

AB1 MANAGMENT LLC
Cooper City, FL

Mar 09, 2025
DONALD TRUMP GO DIRECTLY TO JAIL 1 OZ .999 FINE SILVER CARD W/ PROTECTIVE SLEEVE

Andrea
Chestermere, CA

Jan 03, 2025
Wonderful Seller, very happy with my purchase
Very responsive seller, packaging was good and the pendant is absolutely beautiful.
Report
VINTAGE BEAUTIFUL STERLING SILVER MOTHER OF PEARL LARGE CARVED PENDANT

Casey
New York, NY

Jan 02, 2025
Very helpful. Very responsive.
They were very responsive and very helpful with shipping. USPS had paused the delivery and they were really wonderful at communicating with me about it and pushing USPS to deliver it and get the package moving.
Report
AUTHENTIC OMEGA DE VILLE 24MM RECTANGLE WATCH 22MM GRIMA GP VINTAGE WRISTWATCH

Tony
Austin, TX

Dec 31, 2024
LARGE NATURAL OVAL CABOCHON AMETHYST 18X13mm

Sean
Sherman, TX

Dec 23, 2024
Happy customer
The staff was very professional and easy to deal with. I had questions about a piece in an upcoming sale and they went out of their way to accomodate me.
Report
Vintage Coral and onyx pin brooch

Georgia
Wimauma, FL

Dec 22, 2024
Great experience
Modern Jewelry is very helpful, knowledgeable and friendly. Quick to resolve any small issue you may have. Highly recommend!
Report
CHANEL TURNLOCK MOTIF CHARM GOLD CHAIN BRACELET 96A ACCESSORIES

Kim
Brooklyn, NY

Dec 18, 2024
Highly recommend. Excellent auction House
Highly recommend. Excellent auction House. Smooth transaction.
Report
LARGE WIDE WEDDING BAND SIZE 10

Mark
Key West, FL

Dec 13, 2024
5.80ct EMERALD CUT BEAUTIFUL RED STONE

Kathy
Phoenix, AZ

Dec 11, 2024
Large mens wedding band ring

Janet
Cartersville, GA

Dec 08, 2024
"Modern Jewelry" has a large selection of various types of jewelry. One of my purchases was refunde
Report
NEW 14K YELLOW GOLD SMALL ROUND TUBE HOOP EARRINGS

Byron
Burleson, TX

Dec 02, 2024
LOOSE NATURAL UNTREATED DIAMOND Sale is for 1 princess cut natural untreated earth mined diamond

Veronica
Nanaimo, CA

Nov 25, 2024
Excellent customer service
Very responsive seller. Would deal with them again for sure. Very nice people.
Report
2mm MATCHING PAIR PRINCESS CUT LOOSE NATURAL RUBY

George
New Canaan, CT

Nov 25, 2024
Germany Sterling Silver Grape Vine Handle Scissors - 6.5"

Carol
Phoenix, AZ

Nov 24, 2024
Better description by ct size which is the custom for gems, misleading description
Unless you are a jeweler back away.
Report
LOOSE NATURAL UNTREATED DIAMONDS Sale is for 2 round cut natural untreated earth mined diamond Sale

Nancy
Seattle, WA

Nov 21, 2024
Pleased with purchase
Extremely pleased with my purchase. Had this turquoise set into a pendant.
Report
NEW 5.7ct LARGE NEW OVAL CABOCHON TURQUOISE

Heidi
Washington, DC

Nov 18, 2024
Fantastic
I will be back for more. Thank you
Report
3.5mm BRILLIANT CUT ROUND

Anthony
Brooklyn, NY

Nov 13, 2024
5mm WEDDING BAND SIZE 8

Chase
Palm Beach, FL

Oct 04, 2024
This auction house stays in contact until the merchandise is delivered.
I was very impressed by the timelines of the responses to the questions I had regarding my won items. They were packaged professionally and delivered promptly. Definitely a 5 star auction house experience.
Report
AUTHENTIC CARTIER LEATHER BELT GALBEE STYLE SP GP LOGO BUCKLE CLOTHING ACCESSORY

Serena
Chicago, IL

Sep 23, 2024
0.96ct SYNTHETIC OVAL CUT DARK RED OVAL RUBY

Klodiana
Utica, MI

Sep 23, 2024
1 bought 2 items with them and they did not put same package, i had to pay 2 times for shipping.
overall good service,
Report
Modern Jewelry logo
Modern JewelrySep 23, 2024
I am sorry, I don't understand this review. Buyer purchased 2 different items, from 2 different auctions, weeks apart from each other. Am I supposed to wait to see if you purchase another item?
NEW 14K YELLOW GOLD LADIES FANCY CZ SOLITAIRE RING

Gretchen
Holiday, FL

Sep 20, 2024
Superior service!
I had a question regarding an item, and their response was immediate, helpful, informative, and very professional. Shipping was quick, well packaged, and the payment process was easy. I look forward to more auctions with Modern Jewelry!
Report
SMALL SOUTHWEST STERLING SILVER & ABALONE CUFF

Laurie
Los Angeles, CA

Sep 09, 2024
NEW 14K WHITE GOLD SMALL ROUND TUBE HOOP EARRINGS

Matthew
West Hollywood, CA

Sep 03, 2024
Good prices and great service
Love my ring. Thanks!
Report
4mm ROUND CABOCHON NATURAL UNTREATED PIGEON BLOOD RUBY

Bridget
Dallas, TX

Aug 15, 2024
NEW BEAUTIFUL HAMSA BRACELET ON BLUE CORD

Matt
Miami Beach, FL

Aug 15, 2024
Best prices
Excellent prices, my jeweler cannot beleive I purchased it for such a low price.
Report
3mm ROUND CABOCHON TURQUOISE NICE COLOR

Maura
New York, MS

Jul 25, 2024
14K YELLOW GOLD STUD CZ EARRINGS SCREW BACK TIARA

John
Los Angeles, CA

Jul 22, 2024
TURQUOISE ENAMEL FASHION JEWELRY RING

Donna
Bartlesville, OK

Jul 09, 2024
I LOVE THIS RING!
I LOVE THIS RING!!
Report
10.00 Carat Sapphire 0.36 Carat Diamond 18k Yellow Gold Ring

Pauline
Brooklyn, NY

Jul 09, 2024
As described
Bid and won another beautiful gemstone which was exactly as described and in great condition. Bidding was smooth and the final payment was easy
Report
LARGE OVAL CABACHON MALACHITE GEMSTONE 18.8ct