American Antique Auctions, NJ - Read over 303 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for American Antique Auctions (303)

badge TOP RATED
4.5 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments

1-50 of 303 Reviews

James
Braintree, VT

Apr 19, 2026
no
NICE ITEM SHIPPING WAS HIGH BUT NOT A. A. A. FAULT IT WAS LIVE AUCTIONEER OVER CHARGING
Report
Lionel 2344C NYC F3 B-Unit NMint in Box

Steven
Waukesha, WI

Apr 18, 2026
Rail King Doodle Bug Balt & Ohio Box Never Run

Danny
Bethesda, MD

Apr 18, 2026
Marklin 1 Gauge Early Rolling Stock

John
Washington, DC

Apr 17, 2026
Great people to work with.
Quick response with any questions or concerns. Will definitely bid with again.
Report
Brass Painted Capital Transit Trolley Pair

Winlin
Beaverfalls, PA

Apr 17, 2026
Feedback
Received my order and it was delivered in a timely manner. And as described. Will gladly do business with you again.
Report
Lionel ZW 275 Transformer in Box

Patricia
Onancock, VA

Apr 17, 2026
Japan Visible PIston Tin Litho Friction Racer, 50's

Ken
Williston Park, NY

Apr 17, 2026
Very helpful and professional service
Very helpful and provided both good advice and quick shipping for the lot at a lower price than was cited before the auction. Coordination with the shipper and speed of delivery was superb. I am most pleased with the service I got.
Report
Marklin 1 Gauge 3 Rail Straight Track 32 Original

LARRYS COLLECTIBLES
Miami, FL

Feb 12, 2026
A + + + + + + + + +
A + + + + + + + + + +
Report
1940s Joe DiMaggio Sports Club Ring Scarce

Kenneth
Plymouth, MI

Dec 24, 2025
HONEST AUCTION HOUSE
HONEST AUCTION HOUSE WITH GREAT SERVICE
Report

Mary
Pittsgrove, NJ

Dec 21, 2025

Gary
Milford, MI

Dec 21, 2025
Great Experience!
One of LiveAuctioneers finest sellers! Fast to Send, HIGHLY Recommend, Would do Again! Great communication + Awesome Packaging gets this seller A + + + + +
Report

Michael
Lititz, PA

Dec 20, 2025

Paul
Ridgewood, NJ

Dec 20, 2025
Smooth Process
Good communication, good value, reasonable shipping. Everything as it should be.
Report

Jeff
Nazareth, PA

Dec 20, 2025

Dennis
Fletcher, NC

Dec 11, 2025
Very good service graet company to use!
Graet service
Report

Clint
Ridgecrest, CA

Nov 15, 2025
Easy and Quick Payment and Shipping
Very responsive and quick in shipping items.
Report
Autohobby Trucks in Box

Glenn
Monroe, CT

Oct 31, 2025
1960s Marx Hot Rod Nutty Mad Moysha Car Boat

Vince
Westville, NJ

Oct 31, 2025
Wolverine Press & Go Tin Taxi Cab

Michael
Garner, NC

Oct 31, 2025
1939 Hubley Auto Hauler & 4 Cars

Stephen
Springfield, VA

Oct 31, 2025
Trustworthy auction house.
Items were well represented by the auction house, well packaged and arrived quickly. I have purchased from them before and was very happy. I will definitely visit their auctions again. Thank you for an excellent experience.
Report
1950s Courtland Checker Cab Wind Up

Charles
Napa, CA

Oct 31, 2025
Shipping slow
3 weeks after payment, still have not received items. Items transferred to local ups store, which I thought charged an unnecessary high amount to ship
Report
American Antique Auctions logo
American Antique AuctionsNov 05, 2025
Hi Charles, All the shipping has completed and our shipper has tried to reach you for over 10 days. Always contact us first before posting feedback, we will fix it for you! Thanks!
Hubley Two Tone Cast Iron Take Apart Sedan

Marty
Delhi, NY

Oct 24, 2025
These guys are the best!!!!
American Antique Auctions continue to set the standard for on-line toy and collectible sales. The selection of merchandise is always outstanding, and the customer service AAA provides is the best. I always wish i had purchased more when my items arrive, because they consistently exceed my expectations.
Report
Dinky Toys 181 Volkswagen In Box

Gary
Hesperia, CA

Jun 03, 2025
Nice items
Nice items and reference books
Report
The Art of the Tin Toy by David Pressland

Patricia
Onancock, VA

May 23, 2025
Do Not Hesitate to Buy From This Auction House!!
American Antique Auctions is a pleasure with which to work. Fast and easy delivery of won items. Great items at great prices. Professional, courteous and friendly. Don’t hesitate to buy from them!!
Report
Cast Iron Sky Scraper Banks

Greg
Germantown Hills, IL

May 13, 2025
Great to work with. Highly recommended.
Great to work with. Highly recommended.
Report
Weller Knifewood Vase Pair

Dianne
Wake, VA

Apr 23, 2025
OUTSTANDING FROM LISTING TO DELIVERY
Everything American Antique Auctions provided here was first class. Their accurate, detailed description and the generous number of close-up photographs were extremely helpful. Their responses to queries were friendly and thoughtful. I am especially grateful for their recommended shipper, Christian and crew at UPS Store # 4157 for their care in packing and shipping this piece.
Report
Nicholas Ortiz Double Olla Pottery

Ricardo
's-gravenhage, NL

Feb 04, 2025
great service!
wonderful book en a great service!
Report
Janie Bell 1940 Black Children's Book Ellen Tarry

Robert
Willoughby, OH

Dec 27, 2024
Kilgore Express Flyer, Champion & Kenton Wagons

Chris
Burlington, WI

Nov 29, 2024
Great 1835 Foot Artillery sword!
The items, were what I wanted and expected. Shipping was timely. Thanks
Report
1844 History of the Indians of North & South America

Brian
Englewood, FL

Nov 25, 2024
Pittsburgh Crackle Glass Reverse Painted Shade Lamp

Maria
Jacksonville, FL

Nov 22, 2024
Shipping was fast
Good selection of items
Report
Arcade Tractor and Planter

John
Beverly Hills, MI

Nov 22, 2024
Great pot!
Recommend American Antique Auctions!
Report
Roseville Pinecone Vase

Tom
Columbus, OH

Nov 22, 2024
Four Race Cars Wind Ups & Slush

Danny
Chester, NJ

Nov 22, 2024
Distler German TIn Bizzy Lizzie Win Up Toy

Greg
Montpelier, VT

Aug 27, 2024

Gerald
Bristol, CT

Aug 17, 2024
Mint in Package Marx, Revel, Tyco HO Signs & Figures

Richard
Winthrop, ME

Aug 06, 2024
Matchbox Lot Ambulances & Trailer

James
Lawrence, KS

Aug 02, 2024
Weller Arts & Crafts Pottery Lot

Danny
Chester, NJ

Aug 02, 2024
Always a pleasure to deal with.
Purchased from several of their auctions; always professional and helpful.
Report
1958 Chevrolet Impala Steering Wheel Original

Michael
Terre Haute, IN

May 28, 2024
Great Service
Great Service
Report
Marx & German Tin Cowboys with Lasso

Volodymyr
Wilton, CT

May 24, 2024
Thanks
Thanks
Report
Original 1930s Himyar Tobacco Cigarettes

Perry
Simpsonville, SC

May 24, 2024
? Great
Very responsive and understanding.
Report
German Tin Toy Lot Gama, Arnold, PN

Robert
League City, TX

May 24, 2024
1890s Dancing Man in Picture Box

Pietro
Vittorio Veneto, IT

May 24, 2024
Perfect!!!
Items arrived safely and quickly. I thank Vince for the attention with which he takes care of the shipment. Always interesting auctions, worth following.
Report
J. Chein Tin Banks

David
Tucson, AZ

May 07, 2024
Hot wheels
Great products. Everything was well packaged and shipped quickly will do business again.
Report
Hot Wheel Redline Funny Money

Mar 18, 2024
A-1 Auction
A-1 Items
Report

Jeffrey
Farmington, MO

Mar 16, 2024

Debra
Belvidere, IL

Mar 16, 2024
The Best!!
One of the nicest Auction Houses to work with. Vince was great help and great with information. Love all my winning bids. Fast shipping, easy to deal with!!
Report

Marty
Delhi, NY

Mar 16, 2024

Wayne
Shillington, PA

Mar 16, 2024
Very good service
Very prompt and efficient shipping
Report